European Journal of Alternative Education Studies
ISSN: 2501-5915 (on-line)
ISSN-L: 2501-5915 (print)
Available on-line at: www.oapub.org/edu
10.5281/zenodo.57096
Volume 1│Issue 1│2016
EDUCATION AS UNIQUE SURVIVAL ALTERNATIVE
ON HOMO SAPIENS EVOLUTION
Aenaf Aleahimi
Department of Education and Distance Learning,
Universidade Aberta, Lisbon, Portugal
Abstract:
Human evolution is the lengthy progression of changes. Scientific evidence shows that
the physical and behavioral traits shared by all people originated from apelike ancestors
and evolved over a period of approximately six million years. The intellect, the
magnitude of which divorces the human from all other animals, advanced slowly over
the entire four million years or more of the human development. The intellect is not
unique to the human; it is quite well developed in a number of the other higher
animals. The intellect developed as a control over instincts to provide adaptable
behavior. Education fulfilled in the past a decisive role in the survival of our species.
The arrival of Homo sapiens sapiens, their link to the development of culture, the rise of
teaching and education and the relevance or irrelevance of the educational process in
human survival, are some of the topics covered in this paper.
Keywords: human evolution, survival education, scientific knowledge, social
development
Introduction
Moore (1999: 60) states that "Teaching is intending that someone learn something" and
Savater (1997: 41) referring to the teaching and education it states "The fact that anyone is
able to teach something to someone in your life... does not mean anyone is able to teach
anything
For Moore (1999: 62) "Not all education is education. Teaching is a necessary condition
for education, but not enough" and Savater (1997: 41) indicates about "The educational
i
Correspondence: aneaf.aleahim@hotmail.com
Copyright © The Author(s). All Rights Reserved
Published by Open Access Publishing Group ©2015.
35
Aenaf Aleahim –
EDUCATION AS UNIQUE SURVIVAL ALTERNATIVE ON HOMO SAPIENS EVOLUTION
institution appears when what is to be taught, not merely empirical and traditional scientific
knowledge and then adds, also regarding education "...the process of teaching is never a
simple transmission of factual knowledge or practical skills, but is accompanied by an ideal of life
and a social project" (Savater, 1997: 145).
For its part Camps (1997) states that the function education "is not only to instruct
or transmit knowledge, but integrated into a culture that has different dimensions, language,
traditions, beliefs, attitudes, and ways of life... "
Also, we assume hereinafter the concept of culture that "...means the process by
which a willingness and ability of behaviour passed from one generation to another through
processes social learning" (Garcia and Garcia, 2001: 370)
How to define the scientific knowledge over other kinds of knowledge is a
problem definitely not resolved. While the rationalist position holds that the difference
between science and other types of systematic knowledge is likely to be rejected by the
data of reality; the inductive empirical approach suggests that a statement is scientific to
the extent that their reliability it can be confirmed by experience. In any case, scientific
knowledge is characterized as systematic, according to Ortiz (1997) its validity claims
are defined by the potential reasons they make it acceptable.
Meanwhile, technology is a concept usually linked to science and therefore
under construction and according to Acevedo (1998) is not synonymous with applied
science. In technology have survived some specific characteristics of traditional crafts,
tacit knowledge and skills techniques, that have responded to some human needs
(Acevedo, 1998).
Referring to sapiens sapiens, Garcia & Garcia
:
note that "… adaptation
of human species has been the ability to objectify the experience and preserve the culture... and
become project and incorporation process of cultural property to the activity mental…."
In the definition of Lowy (1999) of culture, valid only for our species, it
incorporates an important element: "It is the need and the ability to express itself through the
evolution attribute imagination, exclusive of the species.
1.
Roots of Education
Homo sapiens sapiens is just one of the several million species on the planet cohabiting
and therefore, is no stranger to the evolutionary laws governing the survival,
depending on the adaptability to the ecosystem and formation of an ecological niche.
In the second chapter of On the Origin of Species, Darwin (1859) said the
variations, slight as they are, if to some extent are profitable for individuals, in general,
they will be inherited by the offspring. Also, "The environment selects those individuals’
European Journal of Alternative Education Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 1 │ 2016
36
Aenaf Aleahim –
EDUCATION AS UNIQUE SURVIVAL ALTERNATIVE ON HOMO SAPIENS EVOLUTION
best adapted to survive, while individual variants less adapted will capitulate" (Savage, 1987:
36).
In Europe and Africa were developed almost simultaneously, two parallel lines
of homo sapiens: Neanderthals (250,000 years ago) and Homo sapiens sapiens (150,000
years ago) respectively, "...to respond to environmental demands of select individuals
endowed with larger brains, able to improve survival itself through greater intelligence,
organization and language... “ngela and “ngela,
:
.
Homo sapiens sapiens emerged with the appearance the ability of imagination,
whose best-documented cultural expression is art. Homo sapiens sapiens as a species
and subject educable, has survived and progressed due to the research brainpower,
whose realization has endowed humanity with greater resources and more effective
defense against all types of adversaries, means of overcoming obstacles and conquest
achievement to perfect ways of feeding and human coexistence, which has had its
genesis in the manufacturing and handling tools.
In small human groups and in primitive societies the transmission process of
knowledge is presented through primary socialization processes including participation
in the activities of adult life through primary cells coexistence: the family, the peer
group, centers or workgroups and production.
But in complex societies, man (Homo sapiens sapiens) requires knowledge
science and technology, developing for it (Gimeno Sacristan and Pérez Gómez, 1998: 17)
"...different forms of specialization that led to the process of education or secondary
socialization
Thus explained it fully justifies the emergence and existence of education, linked
to the production process, based on the requirement of the teaching of scientific
knowledge and technology.
3.
The Human Is the Membership Sapiens Species
Resistance to recognize that the meaning of education is the survival of the
human species stems from the presumption of superior intelligence product of
significant size of the human brain.
With regard to the brain capabilities, Garcia and Garcia
:
write: From
the evolutionary point of view the brain developed to ensure the survival body and not to
perform algebraic calculations, make rational decisions or keep memories ineradicable. When the
brains evolved to produce thought he found advantageous to think of the situation to act on it .
Sagan & Druyan (1993: 353) observed that "…almost every major Western thinkers;
Plato, Aristotle, Marcus Aurelius, Augustine, Thomas Aquinas, Leibniz, Kant, Comte, Hegel,
European Journal of Alternative Education Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 1 │ 2016
37
Aenaf Aleahim –
EDUCATION AS UNIQUE SURVIVAL ALTERNATIVE ON HOMO SAPIENS EVOLUTION
Rousseau, and many others; they have argued that Homo sapiens sapiens is fundamentally
different from other living forms.
This approach is reflected, on the one hand, in the central position that man has
in conceptions religious, justified in the belief that we are the highest product of
creation and, on the other hand, in the terminal place was given to man in traditional
evolutionary conception considered by far time, the end of evolution is man, and can
have its raison d'etre in the search for an argument justifying crush the rest of beings to
our will. The above argument is confirmed by Sagan and Druyan (1993: 354) that "...our
quiet conscience can extinguish entire species on behalf of a benefit."
One of the more ancient attempts to characterize the humanity was given by
Plato who came to argue that man is a biped without feathers . Plato’s definition, in
substance, argues that it is the bipedal condition that makes us different, however, this,
although it is a necessary condition, is not enough. In fact,"...we require the bipedalism to
have a free hand to develop technology" (Savage, 1987: 187).
Sagan and Druyan (1993: 355) confirm the opinion some other authors, from the
perspective of the economy recapitulate: Adam Smith in his justification of free enterprise
capitalism says that the proneness treatment, barter, to exchange one thing for another... is
common to all men and not given in animals' any race. Martin Luther in the sixteenth century
proposed that private property was the essentially distinguished men from animals and similar
reasoning presented the Pope Leo XIII in the nineteenth century. As counterargument as
proposed by Smith and Luther, you can refer to the chimpanzees who like to trade: food in
exchange for sex, back rubs to change sex, betraying the leader in exchange for sex, do not kill my
son in exchange for sex. The food and some rudimentary tools involved the concept of private
property
Sagan, and Druyan,
:
In Henriquez (2003) found a thesis supported in cognitive abilities, relative to
specifically human: What distinguishes us from other living beings is our ability to use and
transmit knowledge. Neanderthal man becomes an endangered species at the time homo sapiens
sapiens begins to draw on cave walls, thus initiating the transmission of knowledge in a nonabstract alphabet, very difficult to standardize, not portable, which differed from tribe to tribe
and clan to clan, but transmitting enough information so that we can tell their children, their
grandchildren, "This is one way of seeing the world" and was a way effective to transmit
knowledge .
Lozano (2003), in a similar direction adds "...really advantage of the human subject is
the ability to have self-awareness, which it does through the instrument or of objectification of
language, built according to the cultural reference ".
However, the skills identified by Henriquez (2003) and Lozano (2003) arising
from our condition of belonging to a species: Homo sapiens, sub species: sapiens
European Journal of Alternative Education Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 1 │ 2016
38
Aenaf Aleahim –
EDUCATION AS UNIQUE SURVIVAL ALTERNATIVE ON HOMO SAPIENS EVOLUTION
sapiens. Ridley (2000: 57) properly said that humans are unique and have advanced
natural equipment, the brain; although the complexity is not objective of evolution and
every species is unique, therefore it concludes that all is something that is very
abundant.
4.
Learning, Emotions and Imitation
Martinez (1999) states that "…education establishes links between symbols source material
thought, marked a decisive step in the evolution of Homo sapiens with what changed all our
psychological structure .
It is, then, the newest creation of communication systems, product development
of a rational-emotional brain which enabled the accumulation of experience and
transmission knowledge in order to modulate certain behavior, linked to survival, as
the origin of education.
On this point Garcia and Garcia (1997: 372) observed (referring to Homo sapiens
sapiens) that "The configuration mode of behavior in the situation, the decision of action, the
mental system that evolution has prepared operates predominantly adaptive purpose and
integration with living environment where you have to survive... " And Gonzales (2004) is
blunt when referring to the role of education as"...the tool that the human being has to fulfil
its purpose as all living things: survive; both in a physical environment (nature) and in a social
environment (society) by providing intelligence (ability to think and feel)" and although it
should be noted that education is not a evolutionary event is to be noted that "...
education as a necessity and activity of structures. It is the result of evolution, and as event, is
an individual event with social mediations without trace in the genetic code... Garcia and
Garcia, 2001: 122)
Savage (1987: 190) is relevant when we remember that cultural evolution is not
biological "...Every generation of humanity passes its predecessor information related to the
environment, social relations and technology. In its purest expression, cultural evolution in
human is by imitation."
And, as a conclusion, the roots of learning are both rational and emotional,
which is confirmed by "…the affective component is essential in shaping all kinds of attitudes,
and skills, including intellectuals" (Garcia and Garcia, 2001: 326) it reveals that there are
primates (including sapiens sapiens) that they learn (modifying behavior patterns)
because they want to be like the kinship relations determine, depending on bonding
and emotional attachment, which is stronger where the relationship mother son.
Meanwhile, the study of mental processes from the point of view of individual
development from embryo to adulthood (ontogenetic domain) is mediated by the
European Journal of Alternative Education Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 1 │ 2016
39
Aenaf Aleahim –
EDUCATION AS UNIQUE SURVIVAL ALTERNATIVE ON HOMO SAPIENS EVOLUTION
cultural and historical development, which has a systematic structure formation
resulting from the assimilation of human culture products: "...the mental or psychological
functions that initially are elemental (natural) are mediated in the process of activity and social
contact with other human beings, through an elaborate system of signs.
In
cultural
development,
instruments
are
created,
Vila,
without
biological
consequences, amplifying the (biological) natural abilities that each individual is gifted.
Therefore, the passage of the natural (biological) to the cultural is mediated by
the set of devices, developed arbitrary and conventional by humans (and other species
of hominids) in the course of social relations and exchanges of its members.
The human activity is characterized by changes and transforming of
environment, going beyond a simple passive adaptation.
It is for this that, although some behavior can be described as responses
organism to different stimuli, but behaviors that involve a principle of activity are
regulated by the higher psychological processes beyond this conception and to his
explanation, that requires introducing the notion of meaning.
Vila (1985) asserts that the signs are established in social relations, accessible
from outside, through another and each child acquires them to regulate their social
exchanges, while going internalizing progressively until being instruments to plan and
regulate exchanges social become instruments to plan and regulate their own behavior
5.
Education and the Threat to Our Survival
Savater (1996) when referring to a possible teleology of education writes that his aim "...
is form human beings and human beings are above all rational beings. The reason is not an
automatic layout, but a social achievement, made possible by a natural and evolving capacities."
But, we must remember that our mental structure in addition to the rational
component has an inherent emotional component. Garcia and Garcia (2001: 327) state
that "... we must take into account the emotional regulatory system is at the origin of
development as a primary mechanism to guide attention."
Furthermore, education is a specifically human action, therefore conscious, that
is intended to develop its own potential; and by developing of these potentials, it
allowed us to overcome constant obstacles on our evolution. This it is not incompatible
with assert that education is a process, outcome and project (simultaneously) of
behavioral changes, cultural, social and personal fulfillment.
Under the same line of thought is consistent with that "Education does not create
man but it helps you create itself
Debesse, cited by Mondragon,
European Journal of Alternative Education Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 1 │ 2016
.
40
Aenaf Aleahim –
EDUCATION AS UNIQUE SURVIVAL ALTERNATIVE ON HOMO SAPIENS EVOLUTION
The human is a living unit whose raison d'etre is the survival, which has been
achieved, so far, therefore largely processes education; hence Plato's claim that
educating is to give the body and soul beauty that are susceptible, it is not consistent
with the purpose of education (survival of the species), but these are a collateral
consequence.
More appropriate, from our perspective, is the position of Valle (1829, in
collection ”ardales,
that "… education purpose is to form a rational human being …to
give useful knowledge and moral habits that requires preservation and perfection",
On this last point, Garcia and Garcia (2001: 125) warn that we, Homo sapiens
sapiens, "... we are not a kind of workers within a production system, but a kind of living
organisms that has capacity to produce… so that the curriculum should not be biased towards
satisfaction of the demands of human capital from scientific and technological system.
Also, Gorostiaga (2000) regarding the issue of technological development aims:
"The meaning of progress based on unlimited material growth is questionable for ecological
implications and social and impossible generalization of this progress to all human beings.
Lozano (2003) adds "Human beings can still harboring dreams of control and power of
prediction, but the chaos, uncertainty, chance says that most self-organizing systems are linked
to countless butterflies… and we must remember that "…man is, according to Nietzsche Cited
by Jaspers, in Soriano, 2002 :: 246) an animal with its evolutionary course not finished ... Man,
you cannot be as your essence ... He needs salvation, healing, freedom and the return to himself."
Then, following García and García (2001: 369) "The survival of the species and the
construction of the human subject do not depend exclusively on the reproduction and feeding,
but also the process of cultural assimilation call education
Meanwhile, Fenstermacher and Soltis (1998: 86) point out that in order to counter
the dangerous man impact of technology in the eco system is required that the moral
virtues and intellectuals to be part of the whole teaching-learning process, indicating
that within the virtues it can include moral honesty, integrity, impartial and fair
treatment
available;
while
between
the
intellectual
virtues
are
rationality,
broadmindedness, the assessment of the evidence, the curiosity, a mental habit
thoughtful and prudent skepticism.
To survive as a species, homo sapiens sapiens has to mold his behavior and
frame within a non-anthropocentric, but of belonging to an ecosystem conception, so
that no longer just about the liberation of the exploited men, but also the ecosystem
over-exploited.
Pérez (1998) states ...education is to help to establish governed convenience; it is about
the concept of efficiency, taking into account the implications for both, to a given community to
the whole of humanity and our planet.
European Journal of Alternative Education Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 1 │ 2016
41
Aenaf Aleahim –
EDUCATION AS UNIQUE SURVIVAL ALTERNATIVE ON HOMO SAPIENS EVOLUTION
All expressions of culture, of which homo sapiens sapiens appropriates through
educational process, should force him to reveal himself "the tyranny of reality" of the
exploitation of man and overexploitation of the ecosystem by man. Referring to the
economic aspects Bautista (2001) notes that "inequality among human beings is one of the
incongruities of planet, within the story ... "having those who have pointed out and even,
unfortunately do) that the economic inequality is inherent in the human condition and essence of
humanity, source of progress, civilization and history.
Botkin et al (1992: 30) state that "Throughout its cultural evolution man has adapted
to their environment, although often unconsciously, configuring whereby it is guaranteed
survival of the species . ”ut to survive ”arbosa, 2004 " ...require information because it
complex and changing ecosystem and social life. This situation is all the more acute in current
society "... as a result of the rapid pace of change in all spheres of life ..."
Conclusions
Homo sapiens sapiens has to assimilate the notion of the impossibility of development
technology that results in abhorrent acts against him same and / or destabilization of the
ecosystem. In order to correct such orientation, regardless of the concept we have on
threats to mankind (as the result of technological scientific development referral), we
must agree that education plays and will continue to play a significant role in the
survival of the species. Then, through culture, through the education process, a unique
characteristic of the Homo sapiens sapiens, we must continue our developmental path
by seeking new meanings, creating works that transcend us and questioning our
achievements in pursuit of survival as a species.
References
1. Pérez, Daniel. (1998). The role of education to the scientific and technological
transformations
2. Savater, Fernando. (1997) The value of education. 2 ed. Barcelona, Spain: Ariel.
3. Tejada Fernández, José. (2001). Education in the framework of a global society:
Some principles and new requirements.
4. Gorostiaga, Xavier. (2000) In search of the missing link between education and
development.
5. Fainholc, Beatriz. (2001). The new challenges of education and training and the
information society.
European Journal of Alternative Education Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 1 │ 2016
42
Aenaf Aleahim –
EDUCATION AS UNIQUE SURVIVAL ALTERNATIVE ON HOMO SAPIENS EVOLUTION
6. Fenstermacher, Gary and SOLTIS, Jonas. (1998) Approaches to teaching.
Argentina: Routledge
7. Acevedo Jose. (1998) Analysis of some criteria to differentiate between science
and technology.
8. Angela, Angela Piero and Alberto. (1999). The extraordinary life story. Barcelona
9. Bautista Garcia, Antonio (2001). Social inequalities, new technologies and
education policy.
10. Botkin, James, Elmandjra Mahdi and Malitza, Mihaela. (1992) Learning, limitless
horizon.
11. Darcy De Oliveira, Rosiska and Dominicé, Pierre. (1975) Illich -Freire. Pedagogy
of the Oppressed. Oppression of pedagogy.
12. Del Valle, Joseph. (1822) report on education. In: Bardales, R. (ed) (1987)
13. Garcia, Joaquin Garcia and Angel. (2001) Theory of II. Salamanca, Spain
Education: Salamanca University.
14. Gillari, Antonio. (2004). Homo sapiens sapiens. The Missing Link? ecological
environment, Year 12, No. 88,
15. Gimeno Sacristan, Jose and PÉREZ GÓMEZ, Angel. (1998). Understanding and
transform teaching.
16. Henriquez, Juan. (2003). The empires of the future are the empires of the mind.
17. Jasper, Karl. (1965) The question about man. Universitas, Vol. III, No. 3, 1965.
18. Soriano, Oscar and Rapalo, Renan (2002) Philosophy, an anthology of classical
texts,
19. Martínez, Migu the. (1999) The sociocultural approach to the study of
development and education.
20. Medina Liberty, Adrian. (1999) The narrative nature of mind and Education
Pedagogy
21. Mondragón, Vilma. (1997) The concept of education in the light of philosophy.
Paraninfo [Year IV, No. 8]
Creative Commons licensing terms
Authors will retain the copyright of their published articles agreeing that a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0) terms
will be applied to their work. Under the terms of this license, no permission is required from the author(s) or publisher for members of the community
to copy, distribute, transmit or adapt the article content, providing a proper, prominent and unambiguous attribution to the authors in a manner that
makes clear that the materials are being reused under permission of a Creative Commons License. Views, opinions and conclusions expressed in this
research article are views, opinions and conclusions of the author(s). Open Access Publishing Group and European Journal of Alternative Education
Studies shall not be responsible or answerable for any loss, damage or liability caused in relation to/arising out of conflict of interests, copyright
violations and inappropriate or inaccurate use of any kind content related or integrated on the research work. All the published works are meeting the
Open Access Publishing requirements and can be freely accessed, shared, modified, distributed and used in educational, commercial and noncommercial purposes under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0).
European Journal of Alternative Education Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 1 │ 2016
43