European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science
ISSN: 2501 - 1235
ISSN-L: 2501 - 1235
Available on-line at: www.oapub.org/edu
10.5281/zenodo.232589
Volume 2│Issue 6│2016
EFFECT OF ONE CIRCULAR RESISTANCE SESSION
ON PLASMA MYOGENIN AND MYOSTATIN OF
YOUNG FEMALE VOLLEYBALL PLAYERS
Ahmad Shahdadi1i, Mahin Najafi2
1,2
Department of Physical Education, Faculty of Education and Psychology,
University of Sistan and Baluchestan, Zahedan, Iran
Abstract:
The purpose of this study was to analyze the effect of one circular resistance training
session on circular surface and plasma myostatin of young female volleyball players.
This article was semi-experimental with pre-test and post-test design. The statistical
population of this study included club female volleyball players of Zahedan city. In this
study, a sample size of 24 was used, who were divided into two groups of 12. Age of
subjects was between 23.9 and 24.5. Sampling was done using purposive sampling
method from among qualified subjects. Measurement tools included a demographic
questionnaire and consent form, digital scales, height gauge, stopwatch, syringes and
blood samplers, free weights and training machine weights, laboratory kits, freezers
and centrifuges, and microplate reader. To analyze the data, the descriptive statistics
were used, including mean and standard deviation and for comparison between pretest and post-test variables, paired t-test (dependent t) were used and independent t-test
was used to compare the mean differences between the studied groups. All analysis
operations were done at the significance level of p
0.05 and statistical analysis was
done using SPSS version 20. In this study, the following results were obtained: (1) a
circular resistance training session had significant effect on increasing plasma
concentrations in female volleyball players. 2. A circular resistance training session had
no significant effect on plasma myostatin concentration in female volleyball players.
The results showed for the first time that circular resistance training is a strong stimulus
to increase plasma myogenin. So, this kind of activity can be a stimulus for muscle
hypertrophy.
i
Corresponding author: email mahin_najafi0@yahoo.com
Copyright © The Author(s). All Rights Reserved
Published by Open Access Publishing Group ©2015.
94
Ahmad Shahdadi, Mahin Najafi EFFECT OF ONE CIRCULAR RESISTANCE SESSION ON PLASMA MYOGENIN AND MYOSTATIN OF
YOUNG FEMALE VOLLEYBALL PLAYERS
Keywords: circular resistance training, myogenin, myostatin, female volleyball players
1. Introduction
Large number of people referring to sports and fitness and weight loss centers also
shows the importance of this issue. This has made fitness experts, including sports
physiologists to do many studies for discovering and providing suitable training
methods, thus taking huge strides in this area. One of the important issues is that most
people are looking for is muscle hypertrophy. The researchers have examined the effect
of exercise training on a variety of factors involved in hypertrophy and provided
training solutions to it. Given the importance of fitness and providing of appropriate
training methods, it is necessary to have sufficient knowledge in the field of resistance
training, in particular circular resistance training and its effects on muscle hypertrophy.
Skeletal muscle is a dynamic tissue that is able to adapt to different physiological
stimuli and external factors (Eschafeno et al, 1996). Repeated training sessions cause
different physiological and biochemical adaptations in skeletal muscle. As a result of
such adaptations, functional capacity and physical performance improve. Growth and
muscle hypertrophy is a physiological adaptations that influence the myogenic
regulatory factors (MRFs) and causes transforming growth factor beta (TGF-β).
Myogenic transcription factors and myogenic regulatory factors play an important role
in skeletal muscle cell differentiation processes by controlling the transcription of
phenotype specific proteins (Kramere et al, 2004). MRFs are basic helix-loop-helix
transcription factors specific for skeletal muscle, including myogenic differentiation
factor (MYOD), muscular regulatory factor 4 (MRF4), myogenic factor 5 (MyF5) and
myogenin (Saboren et al, 2000). MRFs are involved in the regulation of satellite cells
differentiation, leading to transcription of specific genes involved in skeletal muscle,
such as creatine kinase, myosin heavy and light chains, troponin one and desmin
(Mosaro et al, 2000).
Another factor affecting muscle growth is myostatin or growth factor /
differentiation 8 (GDF8). Myostatin falls within family of transforming growth factor
beta (TGF-β) and functions as a regulator of negative muscle mass, and is strongly
expressed in skeletal muscle and then secreted into the circulation (Hulmi et al, 2008 ).
Myostatin deficiency is associated with increased muscle growth. Complete absence of
myostatin in mice is associated with increased skeletal muscle mass 2 to 3 times both in
the form of increased myofibrillar size (hypertrophy) and increase of the number of
myofibrils (hyperplasia) (Hulmi et al, 2008). Laboratory studies suggest that myostatin
prevents the proliferation of myoblasts during myogenesis and activity of satellite cells
and protein synthesis in muscle cells in adult mice (18, 19). Myostatin transcription or
European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science - Volume 2 │ Issue 6 │ 2016
95
Ahmad Shahdadi, Mahin Najafi EFFECT OF ONE CIRCULAR RESISTANCE SESSION ON PLASMA MYOGENIN AND MYOSTATIN OF
YOUNG FEMALE VOLLEYBALL PLAYERS
protein expression differs in different physiological and pathological conditions such as
muscle atrophy, heart failure, HIV, weightlessness, the load applied to the muscle, and
affects the muscle mass (Matsakas et al, 2006). Recent evidence has shown altered
mRNA and myogenin protein and myostatin in muscle in response to exercise. In this
regard, Raue et al (2006) showed that the myogenic gene expression (myogenin,
myostatin) at rest is higher in older women than younger women, and that 4 hours after
a week of resistance exercise in young women, (MYOD) and myogenin increased while
myostatin has been shown to have reduced. Bickel et al (2004) reported a three-fold
increase in mRNA myogenin following resistance exercise. They concluded that some
expressions of MRF increased 12-24 hours after a resistance exercise. On the other hand
Yang et al (2005) reported that resistance exercise (three sets of 10 repetitions with 70%
RM-1) increased three times myogenin after 8 to 12 hours. While a running session (30
minutes running on a treadmill at 75 percent Vo2max), made no changes in myogenin.
The results of study suggest that the peak of gene expression occurs 4-8 hours after
exercise and then at 24 hours post-workout it returns to pre-exercise levels.
Various studies have shown the relation of reduced the transcription of mRNA
myostatin in muscle in response to muscle activity under various loads, such as shortterm activities, a short-term swimming training (Matasakas et al., 2006), running on a
treadmill and running long on rotating wheel (Wehling et al, 2000), or isometric
resistance training after atrophy due to load removal on the extremities (Haddad et al,
2006). Although the effect of loading on the expression of myostatin has been well
studied, but in this case there is still disagreement among researchers. For example, in
humans, decrease and increase of levels of mRNA and myostatin protein was observed
during one resistance exercise while several weeks of heavy resistance training has been
associated with decreased expression of mRNA myostatin (Kim et al, 2005) and
reducing myostatin levels in the blood stream (Walker et al, 2004). Willoughby et al
(2004) showed that heavy resistance training in healthy subjects for twelve weeks was
associated with increased expression of mRNA and myostatin protein and therefore
elevation of serum myostatin. In research by Hulmi et al. (2006), expression of mRNA
myostatin was determined in men before and after 6 months of resistance training (5
bilateral leg press with 10% RM-1). Muscle biopsy in half an hour before and 1 and 4
hours of practice showed reduced myostatin and its receptor (activin). In research by
Heinemeier et al (2007), 4 hours of resistance training eccentric, concentric, and
isometric reduced muscle mRNA myostatin in female mice, but the impact of concentric
training was more than concentric and isometric training. In Louis et al (2007), external
vastus biopsy showed reduction of mRNA myostatin of 6 trained individuals 1-24
hours after a resistance exercise. The results of Jesnke et al (2010) showed that that 7
European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science - Volume 2 │ Issue 6 │ 2016
96
Ahmad Shahdadi, Mahin Najafi EFFECT OF ONE CIRCULAR RESISTANCE SESSION ON PLASMA MYOGENIN AND MYOSTATIN OF
YOUNG FEMALE VOLLEYBALL PLAYERS
session intense eccentric resistance exercise with one leg and introspective for isokinetic
knee extensor movements had no effect on the mRNA myostatin in 20 young women.
Myostatin (GDF-8) is a protein that is coded in humans by gene (MSTN).
Myostatin is transforming growth factor of TGF β family, which inhibits muscle growth
is through a process called myogenesis. Myostatin is the major product of skeletal cells
that circulate in the body by the bloodstream and ultimately connects to receptors called
muscle tissue (ACTIVIN type II) are connected. To understand the full statins peptide,
we should first become familiar with myostatin. Myostatin or (GDF-8) or (MSTN) is a
member of the (TGF- β) protein super family. Myostatin is primarily produced in the
cells of skeletal muscle and circulates in the blood flows and connect it to its place in the
muscle tissue (ACTIVIN type II) and inhibits the growth and differentiation of muscles.
Myostatin prevents the proliferation and differentiation of muscle stem cells, weakens
growth of muscle fibers resulting in the reduction of skeletal muscle mass. Myostatin
control means an increase in size (hypertrophy and hyperplasia) in skeletal muscle,
increases strength in the skeletal muscle, reduces fat without affecting smooth and
cardiac U muscles without problems and side effects on longevity, increase of bone
strength and repair strength of connective tissue.
Myogenin is one of important biochemical agents which modify muscle mass.
Myogenin and (MYOD) are two important members of MRFs family, which are at the
nucleus of muscle cells and are involved in muscle hypertrophy (Eshedo et al 2004). In
response to stimulation by these transcription factors, differentiation of myoblasts and
and transcriptional regulation of a lot of muscle specific genes occur (Bergstorm et al,
2002). Many studies have shown the role of MRFs in determining structural and
metabolic phenotypes of skeletal muscle (12, 13). For example, Hogez et al (1993) found
that the distribution of mRNA myogenin in slow-twitch oxidative fibers is more
common. Given the importance of myogenin and myostatin in the regulation of skeletal
muscle mass and the impact of resistance exercise on these factors, as well as the
contradictory impact of resistance exercise on myostatin and given most studies have
been focused on skeletal muscle adaptations and changes of myogenin myostatin
versus resistance training and that so far neither locally and abroad, any research has
been done on the impact of one session of circular resistance exercise on plasma
myogenin and myostatin protein level, researchers sought the answers to these
questions and considered the following hypotheses:
1. Does one circular resistance training session affect the plasma myostatin level
among young female volleyball players?
2. Does one circular resistance training session affect the plasma myogenin level
among young female volleyball players?
European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science - Volume 2 │ Issue 6 │ 2016
97
Ahmad Shahdadi, Mahin Najafi EFFECT OF ONE CIRCULAR RESISTANCE SESSION ON PLASMA MYOGENIN AND MYOSTATIN OF
YOUNG FEMALE VOLLEYBALL PLAYERS
1. One circular resistance training session does not affect the plasma myostatin
level among young female volleyball players.
2. One circular resistance training session does not affect the plasma myogenin
level among young female volleyball players.
2. Literature
2.1 Domestic Literature
Asgarpour et al (2015) studied effects of resistance training methods and lack of training
on serum myostatin levels, cortisol, testosterone and male non-trained muscle strength.
34 male non-trained were assigned three groups: experimental (a) (four training
sessions), experimental (b) (three sessions per week) and control. The results, analyzed
using ANOVA Mix and Tukey follow-up test, showed that resistance training increases
muscle strength, lean body mass, decreases testosterone and cortisol and myostatin in
both groups. The increase and decrease in the experimental group A was higher than
the experimental group B. Also, a detraining period increased serum myostatin levels
and cortisol in the experimental group b.
Tavassoli et al (2014) studied impact of a circular resistance training on plasma
levels of acylated ghrelin, insulin and growth hormone in males 17 to 19 years old with
overweight. A total of 20 students with an average age of 18 years, 174.5 cm height,
body mass index of 27.48 were randomly divided into two groups: control and
resistance training. The results showed that growth hormone significantly increased but
the insulin levels did not show a significant difference.
Bagheri et al (2014) did a study entitled the effect of combined training (strength
and endurance) on serum levels of myostatin, follistatin and follistatic ratio on
myostatin of elderly women. 11 elderly women were randomly assigned to one of four
groups: training of endurance + strength (E + S) (n = 9), strength + endurance (S + E) (n =
10), rotation combined (ACT) (n = 12) and control (n = 9). The results showed levels of
follistatin and myostatin did not significantly change after three types of training.
Rahimi et al (2014) studied the influence of Ginseng supplements on serum levels of
IGF-1 and myostatin among Karate players after one-round race simulation.
So 16 of the club karate players were divided to Ginseng and placebo groups by
double-blind, pre-and post-test quasi-experimental design and for a month before and
after taking the supplement and after simulated race round, blood sampling was
performed. The results showed that in the group receiving ginseng supplements, serum
myostatin levels and serum IGF-1 levels was affected by ginseng supplements and
European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science - Volume 2 │ Issue 6 │ 2016
98
Ahmad Shahdadi, Mahin Najafi EFFECT OF ONE CIRCULAR RESISTANCE SESSION ON PLASMA MYOGENIN AND MYOSTATIN OF
YOUNG FEMALE VOLLEYBALL PLAYERS
activity simulated. Serum myostatin levels and serum IGF-1 levels after consumption
had increased compared to before supplementation.
Mohammadi et al (2014) did a research titled study and proliferation of
myostatin gene regulation zone and determining sequence of it in native cattle (Najdi)
of Khuzestan. Blood samples of 12 cattle were taken at Najdi cattle support station. The
results showed that mutations had no significant effect on the boxes and promoter
components.
Zakavi (2014) did a study entitled effect of 12 weeks of combined training
(aerobic and resistance) on serum myostatin levels in obese adolescents, in which 30
obese adolescents were randomly divided into experimental and control groups. The
results showed that the weight (P = 0.004), body fat percentage (P = 0.013), BMI (P =
0.006) and myostatin (P = 0.000) fell significantly pursuant to performing 12 weeks of
combined training.
Pakdel et al (2013) studied effect of carcinoembryonic antigen solution on cell
myogenic enterocytic differentiation. The results showed that pure conventional CEA
trade and environment collected from LS-180 cells had inhibitory effects on Caco-2cell
differentiation, but this effect was observed in the control groups.
Saghebjoo et al (2013) studied the effect of eight weeks of high-intensity circular
resistance training on plasma chemerin levels and glycemic control in male patients
with diabetes type 2. Eighteen overweight inactive men with type 2 diabetes (mean age
48.5 years, weight 79.41 kg and body mass index 27.29 kilograms per square meter)
were randomly divided into two groups (n = 10) and control (n = 8). The results showed
that chemerin levels fell significantly in the resistance training group. Also significant
decreased in plasma levels of insulin and glucose was observed. Resistance training
reduced insulin resistance index.
Boroujeni (2012) studied the effect of 8 weeks of resistance training on signal
factors affecting the satellite cells in male Wistar rats. A total of 20 adult male Wistar
rats of weight of 150 to 250 g were divided were randomly divided into two groups:
control and resistance training. Resistance training group was trained for 8 weeks, 5
sessions per week on special stairs with a height of 1 meter and 26 escalators by
carrying a weight of 30 percent of their body weight attached to their tail. This level
reached increasingly 200% of body weight in the last seven weeks. The exercise
included 4-interation sets with 3 minutes rest between sets. The results showed that the
levels of 2FGF- significantly increased in the RT group.
Assad, MR, Vakili, J. (2012) studied effect of resistance training program on
plasma myostatin level of untrained obese men. For this purpose, 19 obese men
untrained volunteers participated in the study and divided into two groups:
European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science - Volume 2 │ Issue 6 │ 2016
99
Ahmad Shahdadi, Mahin Najafi EFFECT OF ONE CIRCULAR RESISTANCE SESSION ON PLASMA MYOGENIN AND MYOSTATIN OF
YOUNG FEMALE VOLLEYBALL PLAYERS
experimental (n = 8) and control. The results showed that serum myostatin levels in the
experimental group were significantly reduced compared with the control group.
Rashidlamir et al (2011) studied the effect of intensity of circular resistance training on
ghrelin and GH plasma concentration among young women.
For this purpose, 20 young adult women were voluntarily selected and
randomly divided into 4 experimental and control groups. The experimental groups
consisted of three group: group 1 with intensity of 40% RM-1, group 2 with intensity of
60% RM-1 and group 3 with intensity of 80% RM-1 performed exercise protocol and the
control group had no training. Before and immediately after exercise, blood samples
were collected. The results showed that in all three exercise intensity, ghrelin increased.
This increase in the experimental group 2 was higher than other groups, it increased in
all three groups but it was higher in the experimental group 3 than other groups.
Saremi and Bahrami (2011) studied the effect of resistance training on serum
levels of myostatin and skeletal muscle mass among male smokers and non-smokers. In
this quasi-experimental study with a pretest – posttest design, fifteen male smokers and
fourteen male non-smokers were included. The results showed that, after leg press
resistance strength training, chest press strength and skeletal muscle mass increased
significantly in both groups, while the index of body fat (including BMI and fat mass)
did not change in response to resistance training at the same time, serum myostatin
levels decreased in both groups in response to resistance exercise.
Arazi and Hosseini (2010) compared the effect of different intensities of circular
resistance training on appetite level of female and male student trained. The study
population included all student, male and female, athlete of Guilan University, of
whom 45 male subjects (3 groups of 15 each) and 45 females (3 groups of 15 each) were
selected at random, and the results showed that circular training with intensity of 50%
and 65% RM-1 had a significant impact on increasing appetite of male and female
students.
Saremi and Gharaati (2010) studied the effects of resistance training on serum
myostatin and insulin resistance in overweight men. The subjects were 17 overweight
obese men who were randomly assigned to two groups: resistance training (n = 9) and
control (n = 8). The results showed that after resistance training, lean mass and muscle
strength significantly increased. At the same time serum levels of myostatin
significantly decreased in response to resistance training.
Saremi, A. (2009) studied effects of resistance training on bone mineral density
and serum levels of myostatin among male adolescents. In this quasi-experimental
research, 30 young men were selected and randomly divided into two groups:
resistance training (n = 15) and control (n = 15). The results showed that resistance
European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science - Volume 2 │ Issue 6 │ 2016
100
Ahmad Shahdadi, Mahin Najafi EFFECT OF ONE CIRCULAR RESISTANCE SESSION ON PLASMA MYOGENIN AND MYOSTATIN OF
YOUNG FEMALE VOLLEYBALL PLAYERS
training significantly increased the chest press strength, leg press strength, lean body
mass and bone density in the femoral neck, whereas myostatin were decreased.
Gharakhanlou et al (2008) studied effect of resistance training on levels of
myostatin GASP-1, IGF-I and IGFBP-3 in young men. 16 young men were divided into
two groups: resistance training (n = 8) and control (n = 8). The results showed that
resistance training increases muscle strength, and lean body mass and reduces
myostatin.
2.2 Foreign literature
Souza et al. (2014) showed that in response to a set of combined training, myostatin and
regulatory genes associated with it ACTIVIN IIb, FLST-3, FOXo-3a, GASP1 remained
unchanged after eight weeks of combined training, though strength increased found in
both groups.
Ryan et al (2013) also stated that aerobic training associated with weight loss
reduce the expression of myostatin in skeletal muscle and also improves insulin
resistance in obese older men and women.
Ahalt et al (2011) studied serum levels of myostatin, before and after 6 months of
interventional training in lifestyle of 57 obese children and adolescents aged 6 to 16
years. They concluded that serum myostatin levels are higher than before after six
months training intervention.
Schifero et al (2011) studied the effect of 12 weeks of strength training with an
intensity of 70-80% RM 1 and strength endurance training at 80% MHR on myostatin
gene expression and found no difference in terms of the myostatin gene expression
between combined training, strength and endurance training.
Hitel et al (2010) reported decreased mRNA myostatin pursuant to an aerobic
exercise while resistance training has been used in this study. Raue et al. (2006) studied
myogenic gene expression in resting and after a session of resistance exercise in young
and elderly women. In this study the expression of mRNA myogenin, MyoD,
myostatin, Myf5, MRF4 and MEF2 during the resting and four hours after one
resistance exercise set were studied in young women and older. 8 young woman (23 ± 2
years, 67 ± 4 kg) and 6 elderly women (85 ± 1 years, 67 ± 4 kg) participated in a bilateral
resistance exercise comprising knee extension with 10 repetitions in 3 sets with 70%
RM-1. Muscle biopsies of lateral vastus were performed before resistance exercise and 4
hours after it. The results showed that MyoD, MRF4, Myf5, myogenin and myostatin in
elderly subjects at rest was higher than in young subjects. Resistance exercise increases
MyoD (2 times) and MRF4 and myogenin and reduce myostatin (2.2 times) in both
groups.
European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science - Volume 2 │ Issue 6 │ 2016
101
Ahmad Shahdadi, Mahin Najafi EFFECT OF ONE CIRCULAR RESISTANCE SESSION ON PLASMA MYOGENIN AND MYOSTATIN OF
YOUNG FEMALE VOLLEYBALL PLAYERS
Kosk et al. (2006) studied the effects of resistance training three days a week for
16 weeks on myofibrillar hypertrophy and myogenic mechanism in young and elderly
people. 12 elderly women and 13 elderly men as well as 11 young women and 13 young
men participated in this study and myofibrillar distribution and its cross-sectional area
were measured before and after the training period.Transcription and protein level of
MRFs were evaluated as restorative markers before and 24 hours after the first session
and was also evaluated after the sixteenth session. The results showed that the crosssectional area of first type fibers increased by 18% only in young group. Myogenin
mRNA and MyoD increased in young people and old people while Myf5 only increased
in young people. Overall, the survey results show that resistance training 3 days a week
causes more hypertrophy in young people than older people.
Yang et al (2005) reported that resistance exercise (three sets of 10 repetitions
with 70% RM-1) increased three times myogenin after 8 to 12 hours. The number of
participants of this study was 12, with 6 in the resistance exercise group and 6 in
running group. Muscle biopsy was performed in 8 stages, before, immediately after,
and 24,12,8,4,2,1 hours after the exercise for of lateral vastus (resistance group) and
gastrocnemius muscle (endurance running group).
Resistance exercise group participated in an activity with three sets of 10
repetitions and 70 percent RM-1 and endurance group participated in 30 minutes
treadmill running at 75 percent Vo2max. The results showed that, after resistance
training, mRNA myogenin increased 5.3 times after 8-12 hours, MyoD 8.5 times after 8
hours, MRF4 3.7-4.5 times after 2 to 4 hours. In endurance mRNA MyoD increased 5 to
8 times after the activity for 8 to 12 hours. While no change in myogenin and MRF4 and
Myf5 before and 24 hours after the activity was observed. The findings suggest that
gene overexpressed time is variable and generally it reaches its peak after 4 to 8 hours
after activity and 24 hours after the exercise, it returns to its original state.
Bickel (2005) studied the period of molecular response of the human muscle to
resistance exercise. The number of participants of this study were 9 (3 women and 6
men) and at times before and 96,48,24,12 hours after electrical stimulation and maximal
voluntary contraction of the lateral vastus muscle. The results showed that resistance
exercise increases the level of mRNA myogenin (3 times), MyoD (83 percent) and 4
protein attached to IGF (46 percent).
Matsakas et al (2006) studied the effects of swimming on the expression of
myostatin in white and red gastrocnemius muscle and cardiac muscle of rats. Subjects
were divided into three groups (1- group swimming second sets of 3 hours, 2- group
swimming intensely for 4 week, 3- control group). The results showed that the
expression of myostatin in the white fibers in all three groups was higher than fibers
European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science - Volume 2 │ Issue 6 │ 2016
102
Ahmad Shahdadi, Mahin Najafi EFFECT OF ONE CIRCULAR RESISTANCE SESSION ON PLASMA MYOGENIN AND MYOSTATIN OF
YOUNG FEMALE VOLLEYBALL PLAYERS
and during two swimming sets of 3 hours, no change in the expression of myostatin
occurred while the 4-week intense training caused a significant decrease in both mRNA
myostatin content of white and red fibers, as that the reduction was more significant in
the white fibers. In general, the results of this study showed that that intense exercise
reduced the expression of mRNA myostatin in the white and red fibers in skeletal
muscle but increases occurred in case of cardiac muscle.
Walker et al (2004) concluded that intense resistance exercise comprising
bending of the elbow (2 times per week for 10 weeks with 80% RM-1) reduces serum
myostatin of six healthy male and intense resistance exercise involving main groups of
the whole body leads to no change in resting plasma myostatin in 11 healthy men (86).
In research by Hulmi et al. (2006), expression of mRNA myostatin was determined in
men before and after 6 months of resistance training (5 bilateral leg press with 10% RM1). Muscle biopsy in half an hour before and 1 and 4 hours of practice showed reduced
myostatin and its receptor (activin) and nd also reduction of catabolic action of
myostatin.
In research by Heinemeier et al (2007), 4 hours of resistance training eccentric,
concentric, and isometric reduced muscle mRNA myostatin in female mice (7-9 mice in
each group), but the impact of concentric training was more than concentric and
isometric training.
In Louis et al (2007), external vastus biopsy showed reduction of mRNA
myostatin of 6 trained individuals 1-24 hours after a resistance exercise. The results of
Jesnke et al (2010) showed that that 7 session intense eccentric resistance exercise with
one leg and introspective for isokinetic knee extensor movements had no effect on the
mRNA myostatin in 20 young women. In Louis et al (2007), external vastus biopsy
showed reduction of mRNA myostatin of 6 trained individuals 1-24 hours after a
resistance exercise. While muscle biopsy was done before exercise, immediately after
exercise as well as 1, 2, 4, 8, 12 and 24 hours after the activity.
The results of Jesnke et al (2010) showed that that 7 session intense eccentric
resistance exercise with one leg and introspective for isokinetic knee extensor
movements had no effect on the mRNA myostatin in 20 young women, while the
muscle biopsy at baseline was done 8 hours after the first session and 8 hours after the
seventh session.
Barr Roth et al (2003) showed that myostatin may also play a role in skeletal
muscle adaptations to exercise. They found that nine weeks of resistance training in
eight young men and women, and seven elderly men and women who were trained
and healthy, led to a 37% reduction of mRNA myostatin in human subjects.
European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science - Volume 2 │ Issue 6 │ 2016
103
Ahmad Shahdadi, Mahin Najafi EFFECT OF ONE CIRCULAR RESISTANCE SESSION ON PLASMA MYOGENIN AND MYOSTATIN OF
YOUNG FEMALE VOLLEYBALL PLAYERS
3. Methodology
3.1 Statistical population & Sample
The population consisted of female club volleyball players of Zahedan city. In this
study, the sample size was 24, which was divided to two groups of 12. Samples were
selected using purposive sampling method; those who qualified in terms of conditions
of inclusion in the study were selected voluntarily as follows.
After coordination and obtaining the permission of the Physical Education
Department and relevant authorities, notification was done using statements inviting
female volleyball players to participate in the research project. To determine the level of
health and physical activity, they were asked to fill in the health and physical activity
questionnaire. Through information obtained from the questionnaires, people with a
history of cardiovascular disease, hypertension, diabetes or certain drug use were
identified and were barred from participating in the research. The participants were
asked to avoid extreme physical exertion foods containing caffeine 24 hours before the
sports test. At the end, the subjects were asked to sign the consent form after reading
the full details of its.
3.2 Research Tools
1. Personal and medical information questionnaire and consent form (Appendix A
and B)
2. Seca digital scale with an accuracy of 0.1 kg for the measurement of body weight
3. Height gauge for measuring height with precision of 0.01 cm
4. Stopwatch (Qiu Qiu models HS43) to control resting time between sets
5. Syringes and blood collection equipment (20 cc syringes, needle no. 20 or 18, test
tubes, alcohol, medical cotton and medical white glue)
6. Free weights and machine weights
7. ELISA and EIA laboratory kits for measuring myogenin and ELISA Kit for
Myostatin (MSTN)
8. Freezer and centrifuges for maintenance and isolating plasma of blood samples
9. Microplate reader devices model Elx800 for laboratory measurements of
hormones
3.3 Data analysis method
In this study, descriptive statistics such as mean and standard deviation was used and
for comparison between difference of pre-test and post-test of variables of research, the
paired t-test (dependent t) were used and independent t test was used to compare the
European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science - Volume 2 │ Issue 6 │ 2016
104
Ahmad Shahdadi, Mahin Najafi EFFECT OF ONE CIRCULAR RESISTANCE SESSION ON PLASMA MYOGENIN AND MYOSTATIN OF
YOUNG FEMALE VOLLEYBALL PLAYERS
mean differences the study groups. All analyses were performed at the significance
level of p 0.05 using SPSS version 20.
4. Results
H1: One circular resistance training session does not affect the plasma myostatin level
among young female volleyball players.
First, using the Kolmogorov-Smirnov test, normality condition of data was test to
ensure that data were statistically normal. Therefore, the use of parametric statistical
analysis is permitted.
Table 1: The results of paired t-test to compare pre-test and post-test
plasma levels of myogenin
Variable
Myogenin (pg/ml)
groups
pre-test
post-test
t
P
Circular training
53/10±43/75
61/12±43/152
-241/15
000/0
Control
01/11±86/73
55/10±71/73
162/0
887/0
Table 2: The results of the independent t-test to compare changes in
plasma levels of myogenin
Variable
Myogenin (pg/ml)
groups
Circular training
Control
pre-test – post-test
+37/13±30/77
t
P
04/15
000/0
-34/2±14/0
According to the findings of Table 1, it can be seen a significant increase (P<0.001)
existed in the plasma myogenin of subjects in the circular resistance exercise group, but
the control group showed no significant difference in plasma concentration of
myogenin (P = 0. 887). Comparison of the difference between the values generated
between the groups (Table 2), significant differences (P<0.001) between the two groups
was observed. Given significant difference, the first null hypothesis was rejected and
the first hypothesis was confirmed, in other words, a circular resistance training session
has significant effect on increasing plasma myogenin concentrations in female
volleyball players. Thus, the first research hypothesis is rejected.
The findings were consistent with Bickel et al (2004) and Yang et al. (2005). Bickel
et al (2004) reported a three-fold increase in mRNA myogenin following resistance
exercise. They concluded that the expression of some MRFs 12-24 hours after a
resistance exercise increases. Yang et al (2005) reported that resistance exercise (three
sets of 10 repetitions with 70% RM-1) increased three times myogenin after 8 to 12
hours. The results of this study were inconsistent with Raue et al. (2006), Louis et al
European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science - Volume 2 │ Issue 6 │ 2016
105
Ahmad Shahdadi, Mahin Najafi EFFECT OF ONE CIRCULAR RESISTANCE SESSION ON PLASMA MYOGENIN AND MYOSTATIN OF
YOUNG FEMALE VOLLEYBALL PLAYERS
(2007). Raue et al. (2006) studied myogenic gene expression in resting and after a
session of resistance exercise in young and elderly women. The results showed that
myogenin decreased. Louis et al (2007) showed that 24 hours after a resistance exercise,
myostatin level reduced.
H2: One circular resistance training session does not affect the plasma myogenin
level among young female volleyball players.
Table 3: The results of the paired t-test to compare pre-test and post-test
plasma levels of myostatin
Variable
Myostatin (Ng/ml.)
groups
pre-test
post-test
t
P
Circular training
76/0±29/9
95/0±71/9
-121/2
078/0
Control
98/0±43/9
98/0±43/9
000/0
000/1
Table 4: The results of the independent t-test to compare changes in
plasma levels of myostatin
Variable
Myostatin (Ng/ml.)
groups
pre-test – post-test
Circular training
+54/0±43/0
Control
-58/0±00/0
t
441/1
P
175/0
According to the findings of Table 4-7, no significant difference was seen in terms of
plasma myostatin of subjects between the circular resistance exercises and
control groups (P = 0. 078, P =0.001). Comparing the difference of values between the
groups (Table 4-8), no significant differences were seen between control group and
circular resistance training group (p = 0.887). Given the lack of significant difference, the
second null hypothesis was confirmed and the second hypothesis was rejected; in other
words, one circular resistance training session has no significant effect on the plasma
concentrations of myostatin in female volleyball players. Therefore, the second research
hypothesis was confirmed.
The findings of this research were consistent with Bagheri et al (2014), Zakavi
(2014), Assad and Vakili (2012), Saremi and Bahrami (2011), Saremi and Qaraati (2010),
Saremi (2009), Gharakhanlou et al (2008), Souza et al. (2014), Ryan et al. (2013), Schefiro
et al (2011).
Overall, the results showed that one session of circular resistance exercise is a
strong stimulus to increase plasma myogenin but does not affect myostatin. So, this
kind of activity can be a stimulus for muscle hypertrophy.
European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science - Volume 2 │ Issue 6 │ 2016
106
Ahmad Shahdadi, Mahin Najafi EFFECT OF ONE CIRCULAR RESISTANCE SESSION ON PLASMA MYOGENIN AND MYOSTATIN OF
YOUNG FEMALE VOLLEYBALL PLAYERS
5. Suggestions
5.1 Suggestions derived from the research
Given the findings of this study that circular resistance exercise increases the amount of
myogenin, it is suggested that people who are looking for fitness and muscle
hypertrophy use the benefits of this type of circular resistance exercise.
5.2 Suggestions for future researches
1. Given the importance of myogenin and myostatin in muscle tissue growth and
body composition, it is suggested that further research be conducted on the
effects of acute training protocols or different circular resistance training on gene
expression of myogenin and myostatin plasma levels of its.
2. Given the effects of gender and aging on muscle hypertrophy capacity, it is
suggested that response of myogenic factors to sports training be examined in
different groups.
3. Given the increased myogen is a treatment method to reduce diseases such as
muscular dystrophy and muscle weakness, it is suggested further research be
conducted to examine the impact on the myogenin and myostatin of activity or
circular resistance training among these patients, to measure the impact of this
type of training as a non-pharmacological method for the treatment or
prevention of the progression of these disease.
References
1. Arazi, H., Hosseini, R. (2010), Comparing the effect of different intensities of
circular resistance training on appetite level of female and male student trained,
sports and motor Life Sciences journal, (2) 47-53.
2. Assad, MR, Vakili, J. (2012), The effect of resistance training program on plasma
myostatin level of untrained obese men, Journal of Applied Researches in
Management and Life Sciences in Sport, No. 1, Ss75-80.
3. Bagheri, A., (2014), The effect of combined training (strength and endurance) on
serum levels of myostatin, follistatin and follistatic ratio on myostatin of elderly
women.
4. Boroujeni, A., (2012), The effect of 8 weeks of resistance training on signal factors
affecting the satellite cells in male Wistar rats, Master Thesis, University of
Isfahan.
European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science - Volume 2 │ Issue 6 │ 2016
107
Ahmad Shahdadi, Mahin Najafi EFFECT OF ONE CIRCULAR RESISTANCE SESSION ON PLASMA MYOGENIN AND MYOSTATIN OF
YOUNG FEMALE VOLLEYBALL PLAYERS
5. Pakdel, A., Naqib al-Hussaini, F. (2013), Effect of carcinoembryonic antigen
solution on cell myogenic enterocytic differentiation, Koomesh Journal, 14(3)
373-381.
6. Tavassoli, A., (2014), The impact of a circular resistance training on plasma levels
of acylated ghrelin, insulin and growth hormone in males 17 to 19 years old with
overweight, Research Journal of Animal Science, 3(3) 265-269.
7. Saghebjoo, M., Shabanpour, J. (2013), The effect of eight weeks of high-intensity
circular resistance training on plasma chemerin levels and glycemic control in
male patients with diabetes type 2, Olympic Magazine, 20(3) 100-113.
8. Robergs, R. (2005), The fundamental principles of sports physiology (Trans. A.
Gaeini, V. Dabidi Roshan. Tehran: SAMT.
9. Rahimi, A., Mirdar, Sh., Baghban, H., (2014), The influence of Ginseng
supplements on serum levels of IGF-1 and myostatin among Karate players after
one-round race simulation, Metabolism and training journal, 3 F(2), 167-179.
10. Rashidlamir, A., Mirzendehdel, Z., Ravasi, A., (2011), The effect of intensity of
circular resistance training on ghrelin and GH plasma concentration among
young women, Journal of Sport Life Sciences, (15) 107-120.
11. Zakavi (2014), The effect of 12 weeks of combined training (aerobic and
resistance) on plasma myostatin levels in obese adolescents, Journal of motor and
sports sciences, 7(13) 67-80.
12. Saremi, A., Gharaati, M. (2010), The effects of resistance training on serum
myostatin and insulin resistance in overweight men, Journal of Sport Life
Sciences, (4) 93-108.
13. Saremi (2011). Effects of resistance training on serum levels of myostatin and
muscle mass OF male smokers and non-smokers. Cell and tissue journal, (9) 1-15.
14. Saremi, A. (2009), The effects of resistance training on bone mineral density and
serum levels of myostatin among male adolescents. Arak University of Medical
Sciences.
15. Saremi, A., (2009), The effect of resistance training on bone mineral density and
serum myostatin levels in young men, Arak Journal of Medical Sciences, 12(2)
89-97.
16. Saremi, A., Bahrami, A. (2011), Effect of resistance training on serum levels of
myostatin and skeletal muscle mass among male smokers and non-smokers,
Journal of cells and tissues, 2(1) 9-15.
17. Saremi, A., Gharaati, M. (2010), The effects of resistance training on serum levels
of myostatin and insulin resistance among obese men, Life sciences journal, 4.
European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science - Volume 2 │ Issue 6 │ 2016
108
Ahmad Shahdadi, Mahin Najafi EFFECT OF ONE CIRCULAR RESISTANCE SESSION ON PLASMA MYOGENIN AND MYOSTATIN OF
YOUNG FEMALE VOLLEYBALL PLAYERS
18. Asgarpour M., (2015), The effects of resistance training methods and lack of
training on serum myostatin levels, cortisol, testosterone and male non-trained
muscle strength, Metabolism and training journal, 3 F (2) 167-179.
19. Gharakhanlou, R., saremi, A., Omidfar, K., Sharghi, S., (2008), The effect of
resistance training on levels of myostatin GASP-1, IGF-I and IGFBP-3 in young
men, Motor and sport sciences journal, 7(13) 67-80.
20. Gharakhanlou, A.A. (2008), The effect of resistance training on serum levels of
myostatin, testosterone and cortisol among young men, Olympic journal, (31) 343.
21. Mohammadi, Z., Roshanfekr, H. (2014), Study and proliferation of myostatin
gene regulation zone and determining sequence of it in native cattle (Najdi) of
Khuzestan, Iran Animal Science Research Journal, 6(3) 265-269.
22. Schiaffino S, Reggiani C(1996).Molecular diversity of myofibrillar proteins: gene
regulation and functional significance. Physiological reviews.76,2,371
23. Crameri RM, Langberg H, Magnusson P, Jensen CH, Schrøder HD, Olesen JL, et
al.(2004).Changes in satellite cells in human skeletal muscle after a single bout of
high intensity training.The Journal of Physiology.558,1,333
24. Sabourin
LA,
Rudnicki
MA(2000).The
molecular
regulation
of
myogenesis.Clinical genetics.57,1,16-25
25. Musaro A, De Angelis MGC, Germani A, Ciccarelli C, Molinaro M, Zani
B(1995).Enhanced expression of myogenic regulatory genes in aging skeletal
muscle.Experimental cell research.221,1,241-8
26. Hulmi JJ, Kovanen V, Lisko I, Selänne H, Mero AA(2008).The effects of whey
protein on myostatin and cell cycle-related gene expression responses to a single
heavy resistance training bout in trained older men.European journal of applied
physiology.102,2,205-13
27. Matsakas A, Bozzo C, Cacciani N, Caliaro F, Reggiani C, Mascarello F, et
al.(2006).Effect of swimming on myostatin expression in white and red
gastrocnemius
muscle
and
in
cardiac
muscle
of
rats.Experimental
Physiology.91,6,983
28. Kim J, Cross JM, Bamman MM(2005).Impact of resistance loading on myostatin
expression and cell cycle regulation in young and older men and
women.American
Journal
of
Physiology-Endocrinology
And
Metabolism.288,6,E1110
29. Willoughby DS(2004).Effects of heavy resistance training on myostatin mRNA
and protein expression.Medicine & Science in Sports & Training.36,4,574
European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science - Volume 2 │ Issue 6 │ 2016
109
Ahmad Shahdadi, Mahin Najafi EFFECT OF ONE CIRCULAR RESISTANCE SESSION ON PLASMA MYOGENIN AND MYOSTATIN OF
YOUNG FEMALE VOLLEYBALL PLAYERS
30. Louis E, Raue U, Yang Y, Jemiolo B, Trappe S(2007).Time course of proteolytic,
cytokine, and myostatin gene expression after acute training in human skeletal
muscle.Journal of Applied Physiology.103,5,1744
31. Walker Ks, Kambadur R, Sharma M, Smith Hk(2004).Resistance training alters
plasma myostatin but not IGF-1 in healthy men.Medicine & Science in Sports &
Training.36,5,787
32. Jensky NE, Sims JK, Dieli-Conwright CM, Sattler FR, Rice JC, Schroeder
ET(2010).Training does not influence myostatin and follistatin mRNA expression
in young women.Journal of strength and conditioning research/National
Strength & Conditioning Association.24,2,522
European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science - Volume 2 │ Issue 6 │ 2016
110
Ahmad Shahdadi, Mahin Najafi EFFECT OF ONE CIRCULAR RESISTANCE SESSION ON PLASMA MYOGENIN AND MYOSTATIN OF
YOUNG FEMALE VOLLEYBALL PLAYERS
Creative Commons licensing terms
Authors will retain the copyright of their published articles agreeing that a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0) terms
will be applied to their work. Under the terms of this license, no permission is required from the author(s) or publisher for members of the community
to copy, distribute, transmit or adapt the article content, providing a proper, prominent and unambiguous attribution to the authors in a manner that
makes clear that the materials are being reused under permission of a Creative Commons License. Views, opinions and conclusions expressed in this
research article are views, opinions and conclusions of the author(s). Open Access Publishing Group and European Journal of Physical Education and
Sport Science shall not be responsible or answerable for any loss, damage or liability caused in relation to/arising out of conflict of interests, copyright
violations and inappropriate or inaccurate use of any kind content related or integrated on the research work. All the published works are meeting the
Open Access Publishing requirements and can be freely accessed, shared, modified, distributed and used in educational, commercial and noncommercial purposes under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0).
European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science - Volume 2 │ Issue 6 │ 2016
111