European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science
ISSN: 2501 - 1235
ISSN-L: 2501 - 1235
Available on-line at: www.oapub.org/edu
doi: 10.5281/zenodo.232997
Volume 3 │ Issue 1 │ 2017
INFLUENCE OF AGE ON SATISFACTION LEVELS OF
KENYAN VOLLEYBALL LEAGUE PLAYERS
Mugala Bulinda H.1*i, Wamukoya Edwin K.2
Department of Physical and Health Education, Kenyatta University,
1
P.O. Box 43844, Nairobi, 00100, Kenya
Zetech University College,
2
P.O. Box 2768-00200, Nairobi, Kenya
Abstract:
Satisfaction in sports has been a critical issue because of its relation to several
psychosocial factors like leadership and motivation. Demographic characteristics of the
groups under study have also shown to have impact on the satisfaction levels in
physical activity. Based on the self-determination theory, the present study on influence
of age on satisfaction of Kenyan volleyball league players hypothesized that there is no
significant difference among Kenya volleyball league players of different age categories
on the 15 sub-scales of sports satisfaction on the Athletic Satisfaction Questionnaire
(ASQ). The study targeted male and female Kenyan volleyball league players in
national division one and two. A total of 134 players were sampled for the study. Data
were analysed by use of descriptive statistics and t test. Independent group t-ratios on
the satisfaction scale showed significance (p< .05) on Team Social Contribution (t –2.756,
p=0.007), Ethics (t-2.043, p=0.043), Team Integration (t-2.193, p=0.30), Academic Support
Services (t -2.961, p=0.004) and External Agents (t -3.303, p=0.001).The study concluded
that age influence satisfaction in sports and physical activity with younger and older
players showing inclination towards different satisfaction components. It recommended
enhancement of varied satisfaction components by coaches and trainers to maximize
participation and performance.
Keywords: age, athletic, motivation, satisfaction
i
Correspondence: email hmbulinda@yahoo.com
Copyright © The Author(s). All Rights Reserved.
© 2015 – 2017 Open Access Publishing Group
15
Mugala Bulinda H., Wamukoya Edwin K.
INFLUENCE OF AGE ON SATISFACTION LEVELS OF KENYAN VOLLEYBALL LEAGUE PLAYERS
1. Introduction
Satisfaction is an integral part of sport participation and enjoyment. Without
satisfaction, athletes would turn to other sources for potential success and enjoyment.
The importance of satisfaction cannot be underestimated at any age. According to
Chelladurai (1984), the degree of satisfaction in athletes is expressed by the relation of
their performance and the degree to which (team) performance reach or fail to reach
expected levels. Mugala (2000) states that lack of satisfaction in sport leads to dropout
from sport. Petlichkoff (1993) suggests that the level of satisfaction an athlete
maintained during sport involvement also played a role in perception of performance.
Understanding influence of satisfaction on Kenyan volleyball league players is
significant since it gives direction on how these athletes need to be guided and
motivated through their engagements. In Kenya, volleyball is a very important sport
since it is played equally by both men and women at elite level. The sport is also widely
played in Kenyan schools both at primary and secondary school level since it requires
minimal space and facilities. Furthermore, the sport is a common leisure time sport
especially among the low and middle social economic status persons due to the
simplicity of its facilities and equipment. Thus, volleyball is a popular Kenyan sport
and understanding influence of satisfaction among participants in this sport is very
important to the world of sport and physical education.
Studies on satisfaction in sports have been varied depending on methodological
dimension. The target group under study has been one of the determinants of how this
theme has been explored. Others include the instruments used and type of sport being
investigated. The study of satisfaction in sport is a multifaceted one because several
factors contribute to athlete satisfaction. The present study examined 15 different
satisfaction subscales among Kenyan Volleyball League Players. This shows the
diversity of satisfaction in sport. Researchers have examined athletic satisfaction in
combination with several variables, but primarily, leadership and motivation are the
major dimensions. Researchers have had difficulty creating a valid and reliable
measuring instrument to assess athletic satisfaction because satisfaction is a very broad
concept. Additionally, the conceptual frameworks applicable to studies on satisfaction
have been varied. Self-determination theory (Deci and Ryan, 1985) has been one of the
theories that explain satisfaction in physical activity. This theory is based on the
premise that individuals pursue self-determined goals to satisfy their basic
psychological needs to independently solve problems, interact socially and master tasks
(Martin & Nikos, 2007).This has effect on satisfaction among the participants.
European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science - Volume 3 │ Issue 1 │ 2017
16
Mugala Bulinda H., Wamukoya Edwin K.
INFLUENCE OF AGE ON SATISFACTION LEVELS OF KENYAN VOLLEYBALL LEAGUE PLAYERS
2. Review of Literature
Studies in Physical Activity have examined the relationship between involvement in
sports and academic performance. Trudeau and Shepherd (2008) examined physical
education, school physical activity, school sports and academic performance using
review of literature between the years 1966 and 2007. The study established that
allocating up to an additional hour per day of curricular time to physical activity
programmes does not affect the academic performance of primary school students
negatively, even though the time allocated to other subjects usually shows a
corresponding reduction and improved physical fitness. The study found positive
influence between physical activity and academic performance, although there was no
relation between physical fitness and academic performance. The study concluded that
increased physical activity time positively affects the other subjects, however, adding
more time to other disciplines while reducing time allocated to physical activity does
not improve academic performance. The study thus showed that satisfaction in physical
activity leads to improved academic school performance.
Psychosocial benefits of sports have also been studies to establish benefits
derived from participation in Physical Activity. Eime, Young, Harvey, Charity, and
Payne (2013) carried out a review of the psychological and social benefits of
participation in sport for children and adolescents. The study aimed at developing a
conceptual model of health through sport. The study involved a review of electronic
databases of June 2012 and studies published since 1990 on mental and/or social health
benefits from participation in sport. The study reported different psychological and
social health benefits, with the most common being improved self-esteem and social
interaction. It further found that sport may be associated with improved psychosocial
health above and beyond improvements attributable to participation in Physical
Activity. Specifically, team sport seems to be associated with improved health outcomes
compared to individual activities due to the social nature of participation. The study
proposed a conceptual model referred to as Health through Sport. It depicts the
relationship between psychological, psychosocial and social health domains, and their
positive associations with sport participation. It concluded that participation in sport is
important to the community because of the psycho social benefits beside the other
physical gains. The present study may get direction from Eime et al (2013) since the
satisfaction variables under study include various psychosocial issues among the
athletes. A related study by Morris, McAuley and Motl (2008) on neighborhood
satisfaction, functional limitations, and self-efficacy influences on physical activity in
older women had similar findings. It found that changes in neighbourhood satisfaction
European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science - Volume 3 │ Issue 1 │ 2017
17
Mugala Bulinda H., Wamukoya Edwin K.
INFLUENCE OF AGE ON SATISFACTION LEVELS OF KENYAN VOLLEYBALL LEAGUE PLAYERS
and functional limitations had direct effects on residual changes in self-efficacy, and
changes in self-efficacy were associated with changes in physical activity at 6 months.
Studies in physical activity have also explored the link between motivation and
satisfaction. Reeser, Berg, Rhea and Willick (2005) examined motivation and satisfaction
among polyclinic volunteers at the 2002 Winter Olympic and Paralympic Games. The
study required the 2002 Winter Games polyclinic healthcare volunteers to complete a
questionnaire designed to elicit information about their motives for volunteering and
the factors that contributed to their satisfaction with their volunteer experience. Results
showed that there was no significant difference in the motivation or satisfaction
summary scores based on event worked. However, there was a strong positive
correlation between motivation and satisfaction. It was also observed that physician
respondents had a lower mean motivation score than did non-physician volunteers. The
study concluded that there were no significant motivational differences between
Olympic and Paralympic volunteers, but there were several differences noted between
physician and non-physician volunteers. Reeser, et al (2005) further concluded that 2002
polyclinic volunteers appear to have been motivated by a complex process best
described as “enlightened self-interest,” and all were generally well satisfied with their
experience. The study recommended that organizers of future Games need
appropriately motivated volunteer personnel. Furthermore, there is need to create a
rewarding work environments for volunteers at all times. This study gives an outlook
to the present study since some of the satisfaction factors under study border on
voluntarism.
Young-Jun, DeSchriver, Bestmann and YeanSub (1997) carried out a study on
Satisfaction Levels of Elite Track and Field Athletes in South Korea. The general
problem of this study was to examine the level of satisfaction of elite track and field
athletes in South Korea with facilities, equipment, financial support, head coach's
technical ability, training methods and leadership. The subjects in this study were both
male and female elite track and field athletes whose performance in 1997 ranked them
among the top five as their track and field events in South Korea. The list of these
athletes was obtained from the Korean Amateur Athletics Federation (KAAF). Since
there were a total of 22 events for men and 20 for women, the sample included 110
(22X5) males and 100 (20X5) females. Therefore, the sample included a total of 210
athletes. However, taking into consideration that 16 athletes placed in the top five in
more than one event, the actual targeted number of potential subjects was 194. Eightyseven per cent of the subjects (N=168) responded to the questionnaire.
Results of the study showed that of a total subjects (N=168), 90 (58.3%) were male
athletes, and 78 (41.7%) were female athletes. Seventy-two (42.9%) athletes were ages of
18 to 21 and 60 (36.9%) were ages of 22 to 25. Only six athletes (3.6%) were over 30 years
European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science - Volume 3 │ Issue 1 │ 2017
18
Mugala Bulinda H., Wamukoya Edwin K.
INFLUENCE OF AGE ON SATISFACTION LEVELS OF KENYAN VOLLEYBALL LEAGUE PLAYERS
old. One-way ANOVA was used to determine differences in Athletes' Satisfaction
Levels. Results revealed that there were statistically significant differences among
means of the six factors; facilities, equipment, financial support, head coach's technical
ability, training methods, and leadership. The results of the post hoc test indicated
financial support was significantly lower than facilities, head coach's technical ability,
training methods, and leadership.
The study concluded that track and field coaches must discern whether the event
in which their athletes compete is appropriate. If it is believed to be inappropriate, the
athletes must be encouraged to change their event. By doing so, the athletes may obtain
better results and thus experience greater satisfaction. Secondly, it was desirable to
expend more money on providing athletes with quality training equipment needed to
increase satisfaction. Lastly, it was desirable to develop a financial support plan, if
implemented, could increase track and field athletes' satisfaction and thus result in
greater interest in participating in track and field.
A study on African volleyball players was carried out by Morakinyo (2002) to
understand Academic Status of African Elite Volleyball Players. The study, Academic
Status of African Elite Volleyball Players involved 96 African elite volleyball players.
They completed a questionnaire about their present academic status, and intended
academic ambitions. The study revealed that 53.3% had obtained academic certificates,
while 46.7% had not. Also, 80% of the respondents wanted to further their education,
while 20% were not interested. Morakinyo (2002) noted that there was need to
encourage athletes, especially elite ones to attain high academic certificates to open
occupational doors often not available to those without academic credentials when they
are no longer able to sustain their sport careers. The study further noted that the
number of African elite volleyball players without academic certificates might be large.
Academic support services are one of the satisfaction components covered by this study
thus need to make comparison. Morakinyo (2002) showed how many African elite
players have not been keen on furthering their education.
A view on the tactical aspects of African volleyball teams was examined by
Bailasha and Akpata (2002). The study, Effectiveness of Serves used during the 12th
African Feminine African Volleyball Clubs Championship investigated technical and
tactical paradigms in volleyball to determine levels of African volleyball players’
masteries of serves, and how they used them tactfully to determine outcomes of games.
The study showed that only three types of serves were used, the floater, tennis and
jump service. It was noted that the floater was the most used and most effective serve.
Also, teams did not diversify types of serves. This led to the conclusion that level of
African female volleyballers; masteries of serves and abilities to use them to determine
outcomes of games were very low. These findings are very necessary for the present
European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science - Volume 3 │ Issue 1 │ 2017
19
Mugala Bulinda H., Wamukoya Edwin K.
INFLUENCE OF AGE ON SATISFACTION LEVELS OF KENYAN VOLLEYBALL LEAGUE PLAYERS
study in trying to understand satisfaction, performance, training and instructions,
which are key variables under study.
Leadership and satisfaction have also been studied concurrently in physical
activity. Chelladurai, Imamura, Yamaguchi, Oinuma and Miyauchi (1988) investigated
sport leadership in a cross-national setting. The researchers studied 115 Japanese
athletes and 100 Canadian university athletes, and compared the results between the
two groups. Chelladurai et-al (1988) examined preferred leadership through the use of
the Leadership Scale for Sports (LSS) developed by Chelladurai and Saleh (1980).
Satisfaction was assessed through 18 items answered on a 7-point Likert Scale.
Chelladurai et-al (1988) indicated differences between the two groups when preferred
leadership, perceived leadership and satisfaction were compared. Chelladurai et-al
(1988) found that “Japanese athletes preferred more of an autocratic and socially supportive
leadership while Canadian athletes preferred more of training and instruction. Canadian athletes
perceived coaches as more autocratic and revealed more satisfaction in personal performancebased outcomes and leadership, than did the Japanese athletes.“
Another leadership related study was carried out by Aminuddin (2002) on
practice of transformational leadership among Malaysian high school coaches and its
impact on athlete satisfaction with individual performance. The study entailed 162 high
school students from netball and soccer teams. The Transformational Leadership
Behaviour Inventory (TLBI) developed by Podsakoff, MacKenzie, Moorman and Fetter
(1999) and the Athletic Satisfaction Questionnaire (ASQ) developed by Riemer and
Chelladurai (1998) were the two main instruments used for data collection. Also,
subjects responded to demographic information of age, ethnicity, incentives, facilities
and support system. The study found out that transformational leadership behaviour of
the soccer and netball coaches were significantly related to players’ satisfactions.
Additionally, results showed that athletes were more likely to be satisfied with their
performance if they were in good academic standing, and if they had a local Malaysian
coach. Significant finding of the study by Aminuddin (2002) to this study was the
relationship between transformational leadership behaviour and players satisfaction.
Roberto and YeanSub (2001) studied Job Satisfaction among Athletic Trainers in
NCAA Division I AA Institutions. The participants were 138 certified athletic trainers
(73 men, 65 women) from NCAA Division IAA institutions, which sponsored football.
They consisted of program directors (13.0%), faculty (5.1%), head athletic trainers
(16.7%), assistant athletic trainers (48.6%), and graduate assistants (16.7%). Education of
the respondents was as follows: bachelor's degree = 13%, masters degree = 67.4%,
doctoral degree = (13.0%). The majority of subjects (34.8%) had one to five years
experience, 31.2% had six to 10 years of experience, and 22.5% had more than 16 years
experience in athletic training. The study by Roberto and YeanSub (2001) utilized
European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science - Volume 3 │ Issue 1 │ 2017
20
Mugala Bulinda H., Wamukoya Edwin K.
INFLUENCE OF AGE ON SATISFACTION LEVELS OF KENYAN VOLLEYBALL LEAGUE PLAYERS
demographic variables of age, gender and experience. They also used classification of
the coaches’ satisfaction depending on their qualifications.
The study concluded that total satisfaction rank scores indicated intrinsic
variables to be the most satisfying element in the profession. Social service ranked as
the most satisfying variable in total job satisfaction. Advancement and compensation
were the most dissatisfying variables of total job satisfaction. The highest level of
satisfaction was seen in program directors and athletic training faculty. The lower the
employment position the lower the satisfaction level. Satisfaction may be contributed to
the level of compensation, which was seen at various positions. The most dissatisfied
were younger members of the profession: specifically, the certified graduate assistant.
Male respondents had a higher level of satisfaction as compared to females. This may
be related to the dissatisfying score of advancement in the profession. However,
advancement was a total job satisfaction variable, which in general, athletic training
personnel found dissatisfying. As educational levels increased so did the level of job
satisfaction. As the years of experience increased so did the job satisfaction of the
subjects.
Turner and Jordan (2006) carried out a study on Commitment and Satisfaction of
Coaches. The study was titled “Commitment and Satisfaction of Coaches: Which is Important
in the Retention and Performance of Coaches?” The study sought for four main issues;
organizational commitment, satisfaction, intention to leave the organization and
objective performance. Organizational commitment was measured using a modified
version of Meyer and Allen’s (1991) 24 item instrument to measure Affective
Commitment
Scale
(AC),
Normative
Commitment
Scale
(NC),
Continuance
Commitment high personal sacrifice (CC: HiSac), and Continuance Commitment –low
number of alternatives (CC: LoAlt) was chosen. Since the research was concerned with
measure of overall job satisfaction for coaches, a single item measure was chosen to
assess satisfaction. Coaches were asked to indicate their level of agreement to a single
statement concerning overall job satisfaction (“Overall, I am satisfied with my current job”)
on a 7 –point Likert scale, ranging from strongly disagree to strongly agree.
Intention to leave the organization was measured using two items adapted from
a scale used by Meyer et-al. (1993). This included a 7 – point Likert scale, where
respondents were asked how frequent they think about leaving their university and
how likely it is that they will actually leave within the next two years. Objective
performance was measured by asking the coaches their previous seasons win-lose
record.
In conclusion, Turner and Jordan (2006) stated that satisfaction and commitment
were significantly related to the turnover intentions and objective performance of
intercollegiate head coaches. Most importantly, satisfaction had a greater influence on
European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science - Volume 3 │ Issue 1 │ 2017
21
Mugala Bulinda H., Wamukoya Edwin K.
INFLUENCE OF AGE ON SATISFACTION LEVELS OF KENYAN VOLLEYBALL LEAGUE PLAYERS
intention to leave the organization, while commitment had a greater influence on
objective performance.
Conceptually, the relationship between job satisfaction and employee work
performance would seem to be both positive and strong. Research by Fisher (2003)
found that individuals tended to support the “commonsense theme” that satisfied
workers were more likely to be productive workers. In contrast to this endorsement of
the satisfied productive worker hypothesis, the majority of empirical work has revealed
that the relationship between job satisfaction and performance, though positive, is
generally weak and inconsistent (Fisher, 2003). However, despite past results,
researchers continue to study the satisfaction – performance relationship in an attempt
to clarify the “real” association between the two constructs.
In another study, Maday (2000) studied goal orientation and level of satisfaction
in runners. The participants for this study were 68 male and 89 female intercollegiate
cross-country runners from the New England area United States of America (U.S.A.).
Participants were delimited to Division III athletes competing in an organized
intercollegiate cross-country program in the fall of 1999. A total of 10 Division III New
England area colleges in the Eastern Collegiate Athletic Conference (E.C.A.C) were
included in the sample.
Demographic Questionnaire was used to indicate the age, gender, level of ability,
and years of running experience. Level of ability was defined for females based on an
average 5 – Kilometre distance with race time of 25 minutes or higher for beginners, 2124 minutes for intermediate runners, and 20 minutes or under for advanced runners.
Level of ability was determined for males based on an 8 kilometre distance, average
race time as 30 minutes or higher for beginners, 27-29 minutes for intermediate runners,
and 26 minutes or under for advanced runners. The Test of Ego Orientation in Sports
Questionnaire (TEOSQ) (Duda and Nicholls, 1992) was utilized to assess goal
orientation while satisfaction was measured by the Athletic Satisfaction Questionnaire
(ASQ) (Riemer & Chelladurai, 1998) for male and female intercollegiate cross-country
runners.
A total of 175 questionnaires were administered with a 90% acceptance, 10% of
the questionnaires were rejected due to incomplete data. Task orientation significantly
correlated with the following subscales of the ASQ: Individual Performance, Ability
Utilization, Strategy, Training and Instruction, Team Task Contribution, Team Social
Contribution, Team Integration, Personal Dedication, Medical Personnel, Academic
Support Services and External Agents. Ego Orientation significantly (p<. 05) negatively
correlated with the following subscales of the ASQ: Ability Utilization, Team
Integration, Personal Dedication, and Medical Personnel. Age significantly (p<. 05)
European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science - Volume 3 │ Issue 1 │ 2017
22
Mugala Bulinda H., Wamukoya Edwin K.
INFLUENCE OF AGE ON SATISFACTION LEVELS OF KENYAN VOLLEYBALL LEAGUE PLAYERS
positively correlated with Personal Dedication subscale of the ASQ. However, age
significantly (p<. 05) negatively correlated with the Budget subscale of the ASQ.
Ability level significantly (p<. 05) positively correlated with the following
subscales of the ASQ. Team Social Contribution, Team Integration, and Personal
Dedication. Ability level also significantly (p<. 05) negatively correlated with the
following subscales of the ASQ: Team Performance, Budget, Medical Personnel and
Academic Support Services. No significant relationships were found between the
demographic variable -years of experience and any of the 15 subscales of the ASQ or the
two subscales of the TEOSQ.
The Levene Test of homogeneity of variance was used to determine if males and
females had similar variance for each of the 17 subscales. From the Levene Test of
homogeneity of variance, unequal variance was found only on the Team Group Ethics
subscale of the ASQ indicating unequal variances for males and females. The standard
deviation for females (.99) was significantly (p<. 05) greater than for males (.68) for this
variable. No significant (p<. 05) mean differences were found for males and females on
the mean scores for the two subscales of the TEOSQ. However, significant differences
were found between mean scores for males and females on six of the subscales of the
ASQ. Females had higher means than males on Team Performance, Budget, Medical
Personnel and Academic Support Services. Male runners had higher means than
females on Team Social Contribution and Personal Dedication. Maday (2000) concluded
that task oriented individuals scored higher on satisfaction subscales pertaining to
Team Social Contribution, Personal Dedication, and Medical Personnel. Also, women
were more satisfied with Team performance, Budget, Medical Personnel and Academic
Support Services, while men were more satisfied with Personal Dedication and Team
Social Contribution.
3. Methodology
The current study examined influence of age on satisfaction levels of Kenya volleyball
league players. It hypothesized that there is no significant difference among Kenya
volleyball league players of different age categories on the 15 subscales of Athletic
Satisfaction Questionnaire (ASQ). The study an analytical case study by design used the
ASQ developed by Riemer and Chelladurai (1998) and a demographic questionnaire to
obtain the age of the Kenyan league players. The ASQ scale had been validated by the
designer during its development. The same was carried out through expert judgment
by the researchers of the present study. Reliability of the instrument was ascertained
during pilot study of the present study where a correlation coefficient of .78 was
obtained. The study targeted the top levels of volleyball league in Kenya for male and
European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science - Volume 3 │ Issue 1 │ 2017
23
Mugala Bulinda H., Wamukoya Edwin K.
INFLUENCE OF AGE ON SATISFACTION LEVELS OF KENYAN VOLLEYBALL LEAGUE PLAYERS
female players. Data were analyzed descriptively and also by use of t test to test the
hypothesis at .05 level of significance. Ethical and logistical considerations were
observed according to the National Council for Science, Technology and Innovation
(NACOSTI) in Kenya. Data were collected at the training venues of sampled teams after
the subjects had signed the relevant consent form and prior arrangements organized
between the researchers and the managers of sampled teams.
4. Results
Age was compared to satisfaction where t-ratios were computed. Age category
comprised of younger and older players, while satisfaction included the 15 components
of satisfaction on the ASQ. Table 1 shows mean differences and independent group t
ratios between younger and older players on the satisfaction subscales of ASQ.
Table 1: Age mean differences and independent group t-ratios for both younger and older
players on satisfaction components
Satisfaction Components
Younger Players
Older Players
(N=72)
(N=62)
Mean
SD
Mean
Difference
Sig.
t
2-tailed
Mean
SD
Individual Performance
3.8519
1.3805 3.9570 1.0889
-.1051
-.484
.629
Team Performance
4.0417
1.6848 3.8548 1.4706
.1868
.678
.499
Ability utilization
4.0333
1.3925 3.8710 1.1724
.1624
.723
.471
Strategy
3.9495
1.4370 3.7285 1.0776
.2210
.994
.322
Personal Treatment
3.9278
1.4870 4.0000 1.2211
-.0722
-.304
.761
Training and Instruction
3.8194
1.6643 3.7204 1.3526
.099
.374
.709
Team task contribution
4.0231
1.5294 3.6290 1.1845
.3941
1.647
.102
Team social contribution
4.5185
1.1464 3.9462 1.2562
.5723
2.756*
.007
Ethics
3.9630
1.3801 3.5054 1.1824
.4576
2.043*
.043
Team integration
4.3021
1.4456 3.8065 1.1175
.4956
2.193*
.030
Personal dedication
4.4514
1.0662 4.1048 1.1394
.3466
1.817
.071
Budget
2.9352
1.7873 3.0699 1.5879
-.1347
-.458
.648
Medical personnel
3.0035
1.9467 2.5444 1.6256
.4591
1.468
.145
European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science - Volume 3 │ Issue 1 │ 2017
24
Mugala Bulinda H., Wamukoya Edwin K.
INFLUENCE OF AGE ON SATISFACTION LEVELS OF KENYAN VOLLEYBALL LEAGUE PLAYERS
Academic support
services
External agents
3.0000
1.8922 2.1452 1.3572
.8548
2.961*
.004
3.5359
1.7479 2.6774 1.1455
.8585
3.303*
.001
N=134, Equal variance assumed, p< .05, df=132, *-Significant t
The table shows positive mean difference between younger and older players on
various satisfaction components. These included Team Performance (0.1868), Ability
Utilization (0.1624), Strategy (0.2210), Training and Instruction (0.0991). Others include
Team Task Contribution (0.3941), Team Social Contribution (0.3466), Medical Personnel
(0.4591), Academic Support Services (0.8548) and External Agents (0.8585) on the
satisfaction component as measured by the ASQ. The positive mean differences showed
that younger players recorded higher means than older players. Consequently, there
were negative mean differences on Individual Performance (-0.1051), Personal
Treatment (-0.07222) and Budget (-0.1347) between younger and older players, thus
older players recorded higher means on these satisfaction components. Therefore,
younger players had higher means than older players on all satisfaction components
apart from Individual Performance, Personal Treatment and Budget.
Independent group t-ratios on the satisfaction scale showed significance (p< .05)
on Team Social Contribution (t –2.756, p=0.007), Ethics (t-2.043, p=0.043), Team
Integration (t-2.193, p=0.30), Academic Support Services (t -2.961, p=0.004) and External
Agents (t -3.303, p=0.001). Therefore, younger players were significantly (p<. 05) more
satisfied than older players on the satisfaction components of Team Social Contribution,
Ethics, Team Integration, Academic Support Services and External Agents among
Kenya Volleyball League Players. The null hypothesis that there would be no
significant (p< .05) difference between younger and older players on satisfaction among
Kenya Volleyball League Players was accepted apart from satisfaction components of
Team Social Contribution, Ethics, Team Integration, Academic Support Services and
External Agents
.
5. Discussion
Results of independent group t ratios showed that younger players were significantly
more satisfied than older players on satisfaction components of Team Social
Contribution, Ethics, Team Integration, Academic Support Services and External
Agents. On all the significant satisfaction components, younger players had higher
scores than older players. The significant t-test may be interpreted further as follows;
the younger the athlete, the more satisfied she/he is with Team Social Contribution
European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science - Volume 3 │ Issue 1 │ 2017
25
Mugala Bulinda H., Wamukoya Edwin K.
INFLUENCE OF AGE ON SATISFACTION LEVELS OF KENYAN VOLLEYBALL LEAGUE PLAYERS
(satisfaction with how teammates contribute to the athlete as a person), Ethics
(satisfaction with the ethical position of teammates), Team Integration (satisfaction with
members contributions and coordination of their efforts towards the teams task),
Academic Support Services (satisfaction with the academic support services provided
to the athletes) and External Agents (satisfaction with those agents/elements outside the
organization which may contribute to the team). This finding differs with Maday (2000)
on the study among college cross-country runners where she found only Budget
negatively correlated with Age, hence her conclusion that the older the athlete, the less
satisfaction with budgetary allotments. In the present study, older players recorded a
higher mean on budget (amount of money provided to the team by management) but
this was not statistically significant.
Comparatively, this study utilized a different age category in which National
league players were used while Maday (2000) used intercollegiate athletics players
hence the discrepancy in the two studies. It is likely that league teams budget is
sufficient than funds allocated to intercollegiate sports thus need for enhancing college/
university sports budgets. Further comparison between the two studies show that
satisfaction component of Budget was not significant unlike Maday (2000). Regardless
of the findings of the present study and earlier findings, finance is a critical component
in sports either in learning institutions or competitive professional sports as reported by
Young-Jun, DeSchriver, Bestmann and YeanSub (1997) on the study among the Korean
national team. According to Maday (2000), age significantly (p<. 05) positively
correlated with Personal Dedication subscale of the ASQ. This may be interpreted to
imply that the older the runner, the higher the level of satisfaction with Personal
Dedication (satisfaction with athletes own contribution to the team). No significant (p>
.05) difference was found between younger and older players on Personal Dedication in
the present study. The two studies therefore have varying findings on the variable of
age. This shows that research on goal orientation and satisfaction are not conclusive
hence need for further investigations.
The present study found that younger players are significantly more satisfied
with how teammates contribute to the athlete as a person (team social contribution),
ethical position of teammates (ethics), members contribution and coordination of their
efforts towards the teams task (team integration), satisfaction with the academic
support services provided to the athletes (academic support services) and
agents/elements outside the organization which may contribute to the team (external
agents). Younger players were therefore found to be good team players because of their
satisfaction on team social contribution and team integration, a finding supported by
Eime et al (2013). This enhances the position of sports as a socialization agent and shows
that the significance of sports is beyond the academic improvement as reported by
European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science - Volume 3 │ Issue 1 │ 2017
26
Mugala Bulinda H., Wamukoya Edwin K.
INFLUENCE OF AGE ON SATISFACTION LEVELS OF KENYAN VOLLEYBALL LEAGUE PLAYERS
Trudeau and Shepherd (2008). Also, by being significantly satisfied with the ethical
position of teammates, they readily accepted their peers. Therefore, younger players
were found to be good team players with satisfactory ethical behaviours. Younger
players showed the appreciation of sports for promotion of character development as
shown by the study findings.
The finding that younger players were significantly more satisfied on Academic
Support Services is not surprising. This is because most of the younger players are high
school, college or university students (Kenya Volleyball Federation, 2015). It is good
that team managers have considered this and given them adequate support. The older
players who are out of college/school, university could not be interested in the academic
support services, hence the low satisfaction level. This finding helps to show that
majority of the older players are not involved in academic pursuits like their younger
counterparts. These findings concur with Morakinyo (2002) on the study of academic
status of African volleyball players. The study found that 46.7% of African elite players
do not have academic certificates. However, the study noted that 80% of these players
wanted to further their education. Therefore, managers of younger players should
maximize academic support services to ensure higher satisfaction and achievement
among this caliber of players.
The support from school, college/university or community (External Agents) is
particularly significant to younger than older players (Mugala, 2002) because these are
salient factors in schools than in clubs. The close link between sports and external
agents is widely observed in voluntarism as reported by Reeser, et al (2005) signifying
the importance of sports to the community. Also, being less experienced, players in
learning institutions highly depend on support from the fans and the mass media to
highlight their performance and popularity. In summary, sports psychologists have
revealed that external support during competitions is one of the psychological factors
that contribute to team success (Hayes, 2003; Weinberg & Gould, 2015). Therefore,
younger players raised a valid satisfactory component when they highlighted external
agents (support from school/university or community) as a significant satisfaction
component. Coaches and trainers should therefore use this initiative as a baseline to
psychologically prepare their athletes /players because of its positive consequences.
6. Conclusion
Age category showed that younger players had higher means than older players on all
satisfaction components apart from Individual Performance, Personal Treatment and
Budget. Furthermore, younger players were significantly more satisfied than older
European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science - Volume 3 │ Issue 1 │ 2017
27
Mugala Bulinda H., Wamukoya Edwin K.
INFLUENCE OF AGE ON SATISFACTION LEVELS OF KENYAN VOLLEYBALL LEAGUE PLAYERS
players on satisfaction components of Team Social Contribution, Ethics, Team
Integration, Academic Support Services and External Agents.
The study showed that younger players are significantly more satisfied than
older players on the satisfaction components of Team Social Contribution, Ethics, Team
Integration, Academic Support Services and External Agents. Age is therefore a
determinant of satisfaction on these satisfaction components. The older the players, the
less satisfied they become with satisfaction components of Team Social Contribution,
Ethics, Team Integration, Academic Support Services and External Agents. The study
concludes that there is need to enhance budgetary allocation to youth teams since they
show low satisfaction levels. Players in the younger age category are mainly college/
university students thus need to increase budgetary allocation within such learning
institutions. Furthermore, there is need to enhance players personnel commitment to
the team as observed in the study. However, the higher scores reported on team social
cohesion and ethics are positive steps since they show how sports impact on the
socialization of young people. The same need to be enhanced among the older players
by the coaches and trainers through social learning. The findings of this study agree
with Roberto and YeanSub (2001) study on job satisfaction among coaches where it was
concluded that intrinsic variables are more satisfying elements in the sports profession.
The same may be reported among the Kenyan volleyball league players where a
significant number of the players recorded higher scores on social cohesion. There is
need to expound on various social and psychological issues like leadership traits and
their impact on different athletic groups both recreational and competitive.
References
1. Aminuddin Y. (2002). Practice of Transformational Leadership Among
Malaysian High School Coaches and Its Impact on Athlete Satisfaction with
Individual Performance. International Council of Health, Physical Education
Recreation sports and Dance. Vol. 38 .1. pp 26-30.
2. Bailasha, N. and Akpata, D. (2002). Effectiveness of Serves used during the 12th
feminine African volleyball clubs championship. International Council of Health,
Physical Education Recreation sports and Dance. Vol. 38 .1. pp 46-49.
3. Chelladurai, P. (1984). Discrepancy between preferences and perceptions of
leadership behaviour and satisfaction of athletes in varying sports. Journal of sport
psychology, 6,27-41.
European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science - Volume 3 │ Issue 1 │ 2017
28
Mugala Bulinda H., Wamukoya Edwin K.
INFLUENCE OF AGE ON SATISFACTION LEVELS OF KENYAN VOLLEYBALL LEAGUE PLAYERS
4. Chelladurai, P.; Imamura, H.; Yamaguchi,Y.;Oinuma, Y.,; and Miyauchi, T.
(1988).Sport leadership in a cross–national setting. The case of Japanese and
Canadian University athletes. Journal of sport and exercise psychology, 10, 374-389.
5. Deci E. L. and Ryan R. M. (1985). Intrinsic Motivation and Self-Determination in
Human Behavior. New York: Plenum Publishing Co.
6. Eime, R. M.; Young, J. A.; Harvey J. T, Charity, M. J. and Payne, W. R. (2013). A
systematic review of the psychological and social benefits of participation in
sport for adults: informing development of a conceptual model of health through
sport. International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity. 10: 98.
doi:10.1186/1479-5868-10-98
7. Fisher, C. D. (2003). Why do lay people believe that satisfaction and performance
are correlated? Possible sources of commonsense theory. Journal of Organizational
Behaviour, 2 (6), 753-777.
8. Hayes, N. (2003). Teach yourself psychology. Contemporary Books: Chicago.
9. Kenya Volleyball Federation (2015) National Leagues and Tournaments,
Newsletter, Nairobi.
10. Maday, M. (2000). Goal orientation and level of satisfaction in runners. Unpublished
masters thesis. Springfield College.
11. Martin H. and Nikos C. (2007). Intrinsic Motivation and Self-Determination in
Exercise and Sport. Human Kinetics. Champaign.
12. Meyer, J. P., & Allen, N. J. (1991). A three –component conceptualization of
organizational commitment. Human Resource Management Review, 161-89.
13. Meyer, J. P., Allen, N. J., & Smith, C. A. (1993). Commitment to organizations ad
occupations: Extension and tests of a three component conceptualizations.
Journal of Applied Psychology, 78, 538-551.
14. Morakinyo, E. O. (2002). Academic Status of African Elite Volleyball Players.
International Council of Health, Physical Education Recreation sports and Dance. Vol.
38 .1. pp 42-45.
15. Morris K. S., McAuley E., and Motl R. W. (2008). Neighborhood satisfaction,
functional limitations, and self-efficacy influences on physical activity in older
women. International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity, 5(1),
16. Mugala H. B. (2002) Motivational factors that affect primary school pupils in
participation in organized sport in Shinyalu division of Kakamega District,
Kenya. Unpublished Master Thesis. Kenyatta University. Nairobi.
17. Petlichkoff, L. (1993). Group differences on achievement goal orientations,
perception, ability and level of satisfaction during an athletic season. Paediatric
exercise sciences.5 (1)12-24.
European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science - Volume 3 │ Issue 1 │ 2017
29
Mugala Bulinda H., Wamukoya Edwin K.
INFLUENCE OF AGE ON SATISFACTION LEVELS OF KENYAN VOLLEYBALL LEAGUE PLAYERS
18. Podsakoff, P. M., MacKenzie, S.B., Paine, J. & Bachrach, D.G. (2000).
Organizational citizenship behaviors: A critical review of the theoretical and
empirical literature and suggestions for future research. Journal of Management
2000 Yearly Review, 26, 513- 563.
19. Reeser, J. C.; Berg, R. L.; Rhea D. and Willick,S (2005). Motivation and satisfaction
among polyclinic volunteers at the 2002 Winter Olympic and Paralympic Games.
British Journal of Sports Medicine Vol 39,4
20. Riemer, H. and Chelladurai, P. (1998). Development of the athletic satisfaction
questionnaire. Journal of sport and exercise psychology. 20,27-56).
21. Roberto H. and YeanSub J. L. (2001) Job satisfaction among athletic trainers in
NCAA division institutions, Northern State University, Unpublished
22. Trudeau, F. and Shepherd, R. (2008). Physical education, school physical activity,
school sports and academic performance. International Journal of Behavioral
Nutrition and Physical Activity. 10.1186/1479-5868-5-10
23. Turner B. A., and Jordan J. S., (2006).Commitment and satisfaction of coaches:
Which is more important in the retention and performance of coaches? The
Journal of International Council for Health, Physical Education, Recreation, Sport, and
Dance.XLII (4),42-48.
24. Weinberg, R. and Gould D. (2015). Foundations of Sport and Exercise Psychology. 6th
Edition. Human Kinetics. Champaign IL.
25. Young-Jun, Dick D., Lawrence B. and YeanSub" L. (1997). Satisfaction levels of
elite track and field athletes in South Korea. Korean National University of Physical
Education. Unpublished
European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science - Volume 3 │ Issue 1 │ 2017
30
Mugala Bulinda H., Wamukoya Edwin K.
INFLUENCE OF AGE ON SATISFACTION LEVELS OF KENYAN VOLLEYBALL LEAGUE PLAYERS
Creative Commons licensing terms
Authors will retain the copyright of their published articles agreeing that a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0) terms
will be applied to their work. Under the terms of this license, no permission is required from the author(s) or publisher for me mbers of the community
to copy, distribute, transmit or adapt the article content, providing a proper, prominent and unambiguous attribution to the authors in a manner that
makes clear that the materials are being reused under permission of a Creative Commons License. Views, opinions and conclusio ns expressed in this
research article are views, opinions and conclusions of the author(s). Open Access Publishing Group and European Journal of Physical Education and
Sport Science shall not be responsible or answerable for any loss, damage or liability caused in relation to/arising out of c onflict of interests, copyright
violations and inappropriate or inaccurate use of any kind content related or integrated on the research work. All the published works are meetin g the
Open Access Publishing requirements and can be freely accessed, shared, modified, distributed and used in educational, commer cial and noncommercial purposes under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0).
European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science - Volume 3 │ Issue 1 │ 2017
31