Academia.eduAcademia.edu
European Journal of Education Studies ISSN: 2501 - 1111 ISSN-L: 2501 - 1111 Available on-line at: www.oapub.org/edu Volume 3 │Issue 11│2017 doi: 10.5281/zenodo.1066180 THE DISCOURSE ON TURKISH IDENTITY IN HISTORICAL FILMS: THE CASE OF KARA MURAT Eray Alacai Assist. Prof. Dr. Department of Turkish and Social Sciences Education, Faculty of Education, Giresun University, Turkey. Abstract: The film industry that developed at the end of the 19th century played a role in improving the masses, first visually and then aurally. The nation-states that became aware of this situation, especially Germany, began to use films in creating a collective national identity. As for Turkey, it became involved in the film industry with the contributions of Enver Paşa, who was under intense German influence. However, only documentaries, feature films, and films based on the Turkish national struggle were made until the 1950s. In the 1950s, there was an evolution in the film industry, as in every other area of Turkish life. Kostüme avantür films, a genre specific to Turkey using real or fiction characters whose stories were adapted into a film from comic strips, were introduced. These films based on historical figures attracted a great deal of attention between 1970-1980 along with the effect of internal and external political developments. Among these films, the Kara Murat series was especially prominent. The present study aims to look into the discourse on Turkish identity in the Kara Murat series within the scope of collective identity. In this regard, the Kara Murat series shown between 19721978 were subject to a discourse analysis based on such categories as identity, conqueror and Conquest, the other , and us . ‚s a result of the study, it was seen that the Turkish identity discourse in these films was based on Ottoman history. Keywords: film, Kara Murat, identity, collective consciousness, Kostüme Avantür Copyright © The Author(s). All Rights Reserved. © 2015 – 2017 Open Access Publishing Group 418 Eray Alaca THE DISCOURSE ON TURKISH IDENTITY IN HISTORICAL FILMS: THE C‚SE OF K‚R‚ MUR‚T 1. Introduction The process of reaching the masses visually and aurally that started with the shooting of the first film in France was also undergone by the Ottoman Empire. Besides the first shooting, carried out by the Promio brothers in İstanbul during the reign of ‚bdulhamit II, the first film was shown by a French citizen named Bertrand (Onaran, 1994; Çomak, 1998). The films shot in this era were generally short films or documentaries. Enver Paşa, who saw that these films could be used as a tool of propaganda during his observations in Germany in 1914, had the Central Army Movie Theater (Merkez Ordu Sinema Dairesi -MOSD) established. Thus, the path towards the first Turkish films was officially paved (Özön, 1970; Çomak, 1998). As for the first feature films, they were shot by MOSD, which had prioritized documentaries until that time. It can be said that Sigmund Weinberg and Fuat Uzkınay played a role in this change (Özön, 1970). Sedat Simavi also shot feature films on behalf of Müdafaa-i Milliye Cemiyeti (MMC). In the years of the Turkish National Struggle, an organization named OFAD was established by the Grand National Assembly of Turkey and assumed the duties of MOSD and MMC. However, OFAD generally shot documentaries. As in the first years of the Republic, the government could not give sufficient attention to the film industry both due to the lack of required technology and because there were more serious priorities. So, the films shot during this time were actually completed with foreign resources or theatrical productions adapted by Muhsin Ertuğrul Şener, . This situation continued until 1950 and changed drastically when the Democrat Party (DP) came to power. Turkish-Greek relations in particular became tense due to the Cyprus issue, and this situation, as well as the idea of eliminating the psychology of the defeated before the Western world were reflected in the film industry. Therefore, the films shot in this period gave place to the Ottoman Empire in general and to the reign of Fatih Sultan Mehmet and the conquest of Constantinople. This situation led to the rise of kostüme avantür films in Turkey, adapting characters from comic strips, and this type of film increased in number over time Karadoğan, . In kostüme avantür films, regarded as a genre specific to Turkey in the film industry, it is seen that historical events are simplified and materialized with characters, giving perspectives on different cultures, religions, or races and thus reconstructing society based on marginalization (Tezcan, 1972; Scognamillo & Demirhan, 2010; Yıldırım, . Thus, films with historical content gather masses of different ethnic origins and religions on a common ground in history, thereby creating a collective European Journal of Education Studies - Volume 3 │ Issue 11│ 2017 419 Eray Alaca THE DISCOURSE ON TURKISH IDENTITY IN HISTORICAL FILMS: THE C‚SE OF K‚R‚ MUR‚T consciousness. This situation is associated with periodically fictionalizing the process of national identity formation by using various tools. ‚lthough it is thought that kostüme avantür films pursued political aims due to Democrat Party rule, these films continued to be made when the military junta (Regime of the Colonels) overthrew Democrat Party rule on 27 May 1960. Moreover, the concepts of being a Turk and Muslimhood continued to be cited as mutually indispensable elements in the films. It mainly resulted from the fact that the idea of Turkish-Islamic synthesis introduced by Aydınlar Kulübü in 1961 became a matter of discussion in the intellectual world. On 12 March 1971, the Turkish Armed Forces (TSK) gave a memorandum to the ruling Government of Demirel, and thus the military took over the government one more time. This period, marked by political instability and short-term coalitions, came to an end on 12 September 1980 when the Turkish Armed Forces seized power. However, kostüme avantür films continued to be shot during this period, and Fatihin Fedaisi Kara Murat (Fatih's Guard Kara Murat), the first of the Kara Murat series, came out in 1972. Up until Kara Murat: Titans Clash (1978), the last of the series, a new Kara Murat film was shown every year uninterruptedly. The composition of several elements besides the historical films putting a character in the center that started in 1950 were not limited to understanding based on the changes in political power, but became especially important in creating a collective consciousness. So, these films were shot within the existing structure and in parallel with Turkish-Islam understanding G(venç, ; Timuroğlu, ; Kıraç, . The films shot during the period when the Turkish-Greek crisis that began in 1954 and continued increasingly in 1964 became successful in the struggle against the Byzantine Empire. However, the striking point was that the number of such films declined in the aftermath of the Cyprus Peace Operation that began in and they were not shot again afterwards G(venç, 4 and ended in success, ; Yıldırım, . This situation indirectly indicates that the government supported such films; hence, one or two films with historical content were released every year starting in 1965. In these films, the subject was generally related to Turkish identity and sometimes to Muslimhood or the history of the Ottoman Empire, especially bringing to the forefront the conquest of Constantinople and the reign of Fatih Sultan Mehmet. With characters such as Malkoçoğlu, Tarkan, ‛attal Gazi and Kara Murat, who were adapted generally from comic strips, it aimed to support the perception that One Turk is worth the whole world . This trend started with the Karaoğlan series, which is considered to be the first example of this genre continuing until the beginning of the s Karadoğan, ; Scognamillo and Demirhan, 2010). Within this scope, the way Turkish identity was European Journal of Education Studies - Volume 3 │ Issue 11│ 2017 420 Eray Alaca THE DISCOURSE ON TURKISH IDENTITY IN HISTORICAL FILMS: THE C‚SE OF K‚R‚ MUR‚T reflected in the Kara Murat series and the discourses that came to the forefront in this process are the focus of the present study. Thus, it is hoped that the study will demonstrate the effect of historical kostüme avantür films, introduced as a genre special to Turkey, in creating a collective consciousness. For viewing / downloading the full article, please access the following link: https://oapub.org/edu/index.php/ejes/article/view/1220 European Journal of Education Studies - Volume 3 │ Issue 11│ 2017 421